Subscribe to Money Magazine
News > Companies
Bargains not such bargains
Analysts say consumers shouldn't expect to see a repeat of last year's whopping discounts.
November 28, 2003: 1:30 PM EST
By Parija Bhatnagar, CNN/Money Staff Writer

NEW YORK (CNN/Money) - Everybody loves a good deal around the holidays. But if you're expecting to find deep discounts at your favorite stores, you may be disappointed.

Shoppers headed to and from Macy's in New York's Herald Square early Friday.  
Shoppers headed to and from Macy's in New York's Herald Square early Friday.

Early "Black Friday" reports from the nation's malls and discounters indicate that while there are promotional sales, they don't seem nearly as broad as last year. That means consumers may have to scramble to get the prices they want.

One disappointed shopper at the Roosevelt Field mall in Garden City, N.Y., said he was "unimpressed" by the "lack" of deep discounts at Macy's. "The discounts are not store-wide but on select items. I'm leaving to go to Wal-Mart and check out what they're offering."

Most retailers have kept their inventories tight throughout the year. "Retailers know that many people will wait until after Christmas for the big purchases. So they don't want to go too far into the holidays with excess inventory that they eventually will heavily discount," said Richard Hastings, chief retail analyst with Bernard Sands.

While that might improve profit margins for retailers in the crucial fourth quarter, there's also a downside for consumers.

"You will still see 50 percent off on merchandise but maybe not 70 to 80 percent off," said Howard Davidowitz, chairman of Davidowitz & Associates.

Important day for retailers

The last day of Thanksgiving week gets its name from the hope that on that day merchants' financial statements will move out of the red and into the black.

But Black Friday also is a closely watched indicator of what's to come in the weeks ahead.

The National Retail Federation (NRF), the industry's largest trade group, expects sales for the key November and December shopping period to grow 5.7 percent, the largest rise since 1999, to $217.4 billion.

Sales for the same period last year grew just 2.2 percent, the weakest performance in more than a decade, as war threats and economic worries spooked consumers.

But despite the NRF's bullish outlook, some industry watchers are viewing the holiday season with caution.

The consensus among analysts is that holiday spending this year will be solid, if not spectacular, averaging a smaller 4 percent growth.

"The consumer is jittery," said Hastings of Bernard Sands. "Rising debt levels, inflation and higher gasoline prices are all real threats and a drag on spending."

Still defensive

Despite signs of a pickup in the economy and an improving labor market, consumers don't appear to be feeling the Yuletide cheer.

"The economy still has to prove itself and create millions of new jobs," Hastings said. "The consumer is excessively dependent on all forms of credit for spending."

The Conference Board in a survey Monday said U.S. households on average are expected to spend $455 on gifts this year, down 5 percent from 2002.

"The 5 percent drop is shocking," said Delos Smith, economist with the Conference Board, a New York-based business research group. "It indicates that perhaps the consumer tax rebate stimulus that benefited retailers during the back-to-school season has petered out."

graphic graphic graphic
Early-bird shoppers get a start on their Christmas shopping. CNN's Jason Carroll reports from Macy's flagship store in New York City.

premium content Play video
(Real or Windows Media)

Additionally, a survey from the Consumer Federation of America and the Credit Union National Association said 34 percent of consumers polled said they would spend less during the holidays this year compared to last year.

Wal-Mart (WMT: Research, Estimates) earlier this month sent jitters through the industry when it acknowledged that it has yet to see strength in consumer spending.

Follow the news that matters to you. Create your own alert to be notified on topics you're interested in.

Or, visit Popular Alerts for suggestions.

"Wal-Mart's news is a very big deal," Kurt Barnard, an independent retail consultant, said. "There's no doubt that a significant number of consumers are shopping paycheck to paycheck. Most are also waiting for price reductions. So saying that the consumer is still cautious is a good indicator that the holiday season will only be moderately better than last year."

Nevertheless, analysts say it's the discounters such as Wal-Mart and Target (TGT: Research, Estimates) that are expected to ring in the bulk of holiday sales, while department stores will offer the most aggressive promotions.  Top of page

  More on NEWS
GOP tax bill: Here's what people are saying
New tax code will still be complicated despite GOP promise to simplify
Here comes Dow 25,000
GOP tax bill: Here's what people are saying
Former Fox contributor: Rupert Murdoch 'ruined my life'
New tax code will still be complicated

graphic graphic