Translation software still fails - badly
New translation software is designed to make the world your customer, but it's still a long way from being fluent.
DUBAI (FORTUNE Small Business) -- My public relations agency, NettResults, based in Irvine, Calif., and Dubai, employs 18 people speaking a total of nine languages. Through a partner, we work with 58 other agencies in 26 countries. So I was excited to test three new language-translation software suites: If they worked, I could e-mail clients myself and cut down on the pricey human translators we use every day.
First I tried Magellan Pro ($2,000, Language Engineering Co.). It's a slick-looking product with the widest scope of languages. We could translate multiple documents with one click and create custom dictionaries.
I sent translations of marketing text to offices in France, Germany, and Italy. The French was described as "very poor." The German was "a disaster." The Italian response: "You made my day ... I really laughed a lot."
Next was Translation Suite ($150, Idiomax). Idiomax claims to be able to recognize the structure of sentences and correct their grammar. It can be integrated with Microsoft (MSFT, Fortune 500) Office applications. I sent translations to offices in France, Italy, and Spain and asked for ratings, with ten the maximum. The highest score, from the French: two.
Finally I tried Premium Translator World Pack ($850, Systran), the only software with an Arabic option. We translate 15 pages of press releases between English and Arabic every day, so it has to be right. Sadly, I could hardly understand the Systran translations.
- How Congress could kill Obamacare after all
- Dow at risk of longest losing streak since 1978
- Rolling back climate rules won't revive coal or mining jobs
- Facebook's transformation into Snapchat is almost complete
- Why tax reform and tax cuts are not the same
- Ford set to announce jobs, investment in Michigan plants