March 17, 2008: 5:19 AM EDT
Email | Print    Type Size  -  +

Spitzer's bully pulpit

The fallen governor's schoolyard behavior caught up with him.

By Geoff Colvin, senior editor at large

(Fortune Magazine) -- When I heard the Eliot Spitzer news on the car radio, I slammed the steering wheel and said, "Ha! I knew it!" It wasn't that I knew he was a regular customer of prostitutes; I was as shocked as everyone else. And it wasn't that he'd rendered himself virtually friendless in his inept first year as New York's governor. It's just that I knew, and had told acquaintances, that this guy was going to blow up somehow. The reason, oddly, is how often he of all people had failed to behave like a grownup.

For years I had heard strange reports. The words that always occurred to me were "childish," "adolescent," "immature." Former GE chief Jack Welch had told me about a couple of encounters, the most dramatic occurring at the 2004 Democratic National Convention. Spitzer was then going after Ken Langone, former director of both GE and the New York Stock Exchange. "We were having an amiable chat," Welch recalled. "Then - boom - he flipped his lid. He snapped. He started sticking his finger in my chest and said, 'You can tell your friend Langone that I'm gonna put a stake through his heart!'" Langone is no slouch as a trash talker, but this was simply juvenile.

At a dinner, Spitzer once made a point of telling me he had $20 million. How bizarre, I thought. I've met very few adults who felt compelled to tell me just how much money they had, but I've met lots of kids who did.

Much has been made of his episode with former Goldman Sachs chief John Whitehead, but the story as usually recounted misses the point, in my view. In April 2005, the Wall Street Journal published an op-ed piece by Whitehead chastising Spitzer for being overly aggressive. Whitehead later reported that Spitzer then called him and said, in part, "I will be coming after you. You will pay the price.... You will pay dearly for what you have done." Whitehead said he was "so shocked" that he wrote down the conversation.

This is usually presented as an instance of Spitzer's thuggishness, which it certainly is. But of greater significance is what happened next. Through a spokesman, Spitzer called Whitehead's report "a complete fabrication." Understand that on Wall Street and in business generally, Whitehead's reputation for integrity is unsurpassed. Spitzer had flat-out called him a liar. So we knew somebody was lying, and I felt confident I knew who it was. I still do.

More childish bullying followed, most notably his announcement to a state legislator, upon his arrival in Albany, that "I'm a f---ing steamroller." It's a shame that his conduct undermined the work he did as attorney general, some of which - like cleaning up Wall Street's analyst conflicts - badly needed doing. But a man who couldn't behave like an adult certainly shouldn't have been a governor. It could have been worse. It's reliably reported that he eventually wanted to be President.  To top of page

  • The Fortune 40: Best stocks to retire on
    Whatever the market, our trademark long-term portfolio can help you build a secure nest egg. More
  • Meet the stimulus hires
    Just who are the infrastructure and IT workers tasked with rebuilding America? We tracked down a few to find out. More
  • Muscle cars we'd miss
    As Detroit downsizes with a greener car mandate, Motown's hot rods may not be around much longer. More
  • Defying death with Jim Collins
    Scaling a 1,000-ft rock face with the management guru, our writer finds out what makes him tick. More
  • Die another day
    Companies of every stripe are filing for bankruptcy or getting perilously close - and they're not just in Detroit or on Wall Street. Here are 10 firms fighting for their lives. More
  • Ireland's new troubles
    Eire has been hit by a housing bubble and the global slowdown. Can the country once again become the go-to place for foreign investors? More
  • 8 signs of hope for the economy
    Are we on the brink of a rebound, or is it a false spring? Fortune looks at the evidence for an imminent recovery. More
CompanyPrice% Change
General Motors Corp 0.82 -9.64%
Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc 0.04 -8.67%
Alcoa Inc 9.86 0.00%
Advance Auto Parts Inc 42.24 0.00%
Jul 6 9:35am ET †
IndexLast% Change
Dow Jones8,248.85-0.39%
Nasdaq1,787.60-0.50%
S&P 500892.82-0.40%
10yr96 19/32Yield: 3.53%
Jul 06 9:39am ET †
CompanyPrice% Change
Cablevision Systems Corp 18.48 0.00%
DISH Network Corp 16.10 0.00%
DIRECTV Group Inc (The) 23.99 0.00%
Time Warner Inc 24.21 0.00%
Jul 6 9:38am ET †
* : Time reflects local markets trading time.† - Intraday data delayed 15 minutes for Nasdaq, and 20 minutes for other exchanges.• Disclaimer