Email | Print    Type Size  -  +

Prophets of the credit crisis

A trio of economists are talking to packed houses about the grim future of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the causes of the credit crisis, and the failings of ratings agencies.

By Katie Benner, writer-reporter
July 11, 2008: 11:05 AM EDT

Deals on the rocks
Corporate M&A used to be a straightforward affair - but lately even amicable pairings have been turning sour with the markets. Some recent deals in jeopardy:
Hexion/Apollo and Huntsman
Apollo and chemical company Hexion are backing out of a $10.6 billion deal to merge with chemical giant Huntsman, alleging in a lawsuit that the combined companies would be insolvent. Huntsman has countersued, claiming fraud.
Blockbuster and Circuit City
The movie-rental giant pulled its bid for the electronics retailer, citing "market conditions."
Fortress Investment Group/Centerbridge Partners and Penn National Gaming
Fortress and Centerbridge scrapped their $6.1 billion takeover of the casino and racetrack operator after the parties couldn't agree on a reduced price to reflect a slowing economy.

(Fortune) -- Sylvain Raynes, Joshua Rosner, and Christopher Whalen are the power trio that has come to personify today's collapsing capital markets.

Raynes (an expert at decoding the value of complex structured securities), Rosner (who advises policymakers and regulators scrambling to deal with the housing and credit blowups), and Whalen (whom accounting firms hire to find skeletons lurking in investment bank closets) started appearing together on economic panels several years ago. Once obscure, they have graduated from giving small group talks to packing venues like Washington's American Enterprise Institute and the New York Athletic Club in Manhattan. At the latter locale, 200-plus dark-suited regulators, risk managers, and analysts recently filled a wood-paneled room to groove on some insights about distressed assets. Among the gems tossed out to the crowd: "People say we're in the final innings of the credit crisis," said Rosner. "We're in the late innings of the first game, and this is the World Series."

Raynes, Rosner, and Whalen weren't always so popular. Since 2005 they have been telling anyone who would listen that banks don't generate real returns, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will crumble, and rating agencies aren't equipped to evaluate structured bonds. Like many an alternative act, they were ahead of their time. "People said it was easy for us to scream, because we had nothing to lose," says Raynes. "Of course, it should have been much easier for [rating agencies and risk committees] to scream, because they had everything to lose."

The three have serious day jobs. Raynes, a 51-year-old former Moody's employee, formed R&R Consulting with his partner, Ann Rutledge, in 2000 to do what Moody's and other rating agencies seemingly cannot: Decode the creditworthiness of structured securities. Boyishly handsome and a smooth talker, he received a Ph.D. in aeronautical engineering from Princeton before working in risk management at Credit Suisse and Citibank.

Tall, bespectacled, and bitingly sarcastic, Whalen, 49, is a former Bear Stearns fixed-income analyst who co-founded Institutional Risk Analytics with Dennis Santiago. And Rosner, a 41-year-old managing director at independent research firm Graham Fisher & Co., was one of the first to question the lax lending standards in mortgage origination.

In his 2001 paper "Housing in the New Millennium: A Home Without Equity Is Just a Rental With Debt," he pointed out that historically, 65% of households owned houses, and suddenly that had jumped to 70%. "There were no economic justifications for that increase, which could never be sustained," he says.

When not performing, these masters of disaster have more work than they can handle. Investment banks, rating agencies, and Fannie and Freddie may not be fans of their work, but one thing is undeniable: The music of RR&W has become the soundtrack for our meltdown.  To top of page

  • The Fortune 40: Best stocks to retire on
    Whatever the market, our trademark long-term portfolio can help you build a secure nest egg. More
  • Meet the stimulus hires
    Just who are the infrastructure and IT workers tasked with rebuilding America? We tracked down a few to find out. More
  • Muscle cars we'd miss
    As Detroit downsizes with a greener car mandate, Motown's hot rods may not be around much longer. More
  • Defying death with Jim Collins
    Scaling a 1,000-ft rock face with the management guru, our writer finds out what makes him tick. More
  • Die another day
    Companies of every stripe are filing for bankruptcy or getting perilously close - and they're not just in Detroit or on Wall Street. Here are 10 firms fighting for their lives. More
  • Ireland's new troubles
    Eire has been hit by a housing bubble and the global slowdown. Can the country once again become the go-to place for foreign investors? More
  • 8 signs of hope for the economy
    Are we on the brink of a rebound, or is it a false spring? Fortune looks at the evidence for an imminent recovery. More
CompanyPrice% Change
OfficeMax Inc 5.67 -11.13%
Rite Aid Corporation 1.39 -9.74%
Tenneco Inc 10.14 -9.55%
Conseco Inc 2.25 -8.54%
Jul 2 3:56pm ET †
IndexLast% Change
Dow Jones8,280.74-2.70%
Nasdaq1,796.52-2.67%
S&P 500896.43-2.91%
10yr96 29/32Yield: 3.49%
Jul 03 12:00am ET †
CompanyPrice% Change
Sanmina-SCI Corp 0.43 -6.14%
Unisys Corporation 1.77 -5.35%
Cablevision Systems Corp 18.61 -4.98%
Sprint Nextel Corp 4.39 -4.76%
Jul 2 3:58pm ET †
* : Time reflects local markets trading time.† - Intraday data delayed 15 minutes for Nasdaq, and 20 minutes for other exchanges.• Disclaimer