Breaking Views

Don't blame Chrysler's creditors

Caving in to the Obama administration would ultimately hurt the system the President is trying to save.

EMAIL  |   PRINT  |   SHARE  |   RSS
 
google my aol my msn my yahoo! netvibes
Paste this link into your favorite RSS desktop reader
See all CNNMoney.com RSS FEEDS (close)
By Rob Cox, breakingviews.com

(breakingviews.com) -- It's politically expedient for President Obama to blame recalcitrant hedge funds and "speculators" for forcing Chrysler into bankruptcy. But they were right to just say no to the U.S. government's restructuring plan, which treads on the rights of senior creditors.

Caving in to Uncle Sam would have set a bad precedent for capitalism - and may ultimately hamper the president's exit strategy from Bailout America.

Technically it's true that a small group of investors, holding $1 billion of $6.9 billion of Chrysler's debt, played a pivotal role in deciding Chrysler's fate. By not accepting the 33 cents on the dollar they were being offered by Obama's automotive task force, the carmaker had no choice but to file for protection from its creditors.

But it's questionable whether Chrysler would have avoided bankruptcy even if the group had accepted the offer. Bankruptcy allows Chrysler to wrangle greater concessions from dealers, which notably eases Fiat's arrival, and ultimately makes Chrysler a stronger company. Solely blaming the hedge funds is disingenuous.

And even if Chrysler could have accomplished its aims without reverting to Chapter 11, the government's offer alone was reason enough for creditors to resist - and continue to press their case in the courts. Under the government's last proposal, the lenders would have received $2.25 billion in cash, implying a 67% haircut.

Despite being an unsecured creditor, however, the United Auto Workers is poised to retain half of Chrysler's $10.6 billion obligation to the union. That means the UAW gets 50 cents on the dollar even before accounting for the 55% stake in the new Chrysler-Fiat that it is receiving. Equity is obviously riskier than debt, but it's conceivable that the UAW will be made more than whole.

Politically speaking, this would be a great outcome for the president. But the message it sends to lenders is quite clear. Years of bankruptcy law have put secured creditors at the top of the pecking order, inducing them to put capital at risk. Vilifying investors who held firm to this conviction may have the reverse effect. To top of page

CompanyPrice% Change
Beazer Homes USA Inc 5.11 8.96%
Fluor Corp 44.27 -7.79%
YRC Worldwide Inc 1.10 -6.78%
ArvinMeritor Inc 9.23 6.22%
Nov 10 3:53pm ET †
IndexLast% Change
Dow Jones10,246.970.20%
Nasdaq2,151.08-0.14%
S&P 5001,093.01-0.01%
10yr101 6/32Yield: 3.47%
Nov 10 †
CompanyPrice% Change
Electronic Arts Inc 18.25 -6.55%
Sprint Nextel Corp 3.25 -5.25%
Sanmina Sci Corp 8.10 -3.46%
Tellabs, Inc 5.97 -3.24%
Nov 10 3:59pm ET †
More Galleries
6 most fuel-efficient cars These vehicles top their class in fuel economy while offering strong performance, too. More
Pieces of Madoff Many of Bernie Madoff's victims would like to have a piece of the felonious financier. Now they can. This week hundreds of his and Ruth's possessions go up for auction. More
Inside Donald Trump's private jet The real estate mogul's upgrading to a larger private jet, so his 1968 Boeing 727, estimated to cost between $4 million and $8 million, is on the market. More
Sponsors

© 2009 Cable News Network. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2009 BigCharts.com Inc. All rights reserved. Please see our Terms of Use.
MarketWatch, the MarketWatch logo, and BigCharts are registered trademarks of MarketWatch, Inc.
Intraday data provided by Interactive Data Real-Time Services and subject to the Terms of Use.
Intraday data is at least 20-minutes delayed. All times are ET.
Historical, current end-of-day data, and splits data provided by Interactive Data Pricing and Reference Data.
Fundamental data provided by Morningstar, Inc..
SEC Filings data provided by Edgar Online Inc..
Earnings data provided by FactSet CallStreet, LLC.