NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) -- Two years after the credit squeeze began, Americans are still pulling back.
A government report released Thursday showed that consumer credit fell at an annual rate of 4.5% in May, making it the fourth consecutive month of declining credit.
Total consumer credit fell a seasonally adjusted $9.1 billion to $2.4 trillion, the Federal Reserve reported.
Economists had predicted a decline in total borrowing of $3 billion, according to a consensus estimate from Briefing.com.
"No one is shocked to see another decrease," said Tim Quinlan, an economist with Wells Fargo. "This report, combined with disappointing May retail sales report, is the latest indication of weakness in consumer spending."
The decline was led by a 10.5% drop in revolving credit, which includes credit card debt.
Non-revolving credit -- car, personal and student loans, among other things -- also decreased. It declined by $1.82 billion, or 1.5%.
The Fed on Thursday also revised its April figures. After originally reporting that credit had gone up by $1 billion, it now says credit decreased by $14.9 billion.
Quinlan expects consumer credit to continue to decline "as consumers try to gradually repair their balance sheets."
And consumers are being more conservative.
SpaceX does something that hasn't been done before. It sends a recycled rocket to space for the first time. More
The nation's long-term debt is likely to double as a share of the economy if nothing changes, according to the Congressional Budget Office. Trump's proposals potentially could make those projections worse. More
In 1998, Ntsiki Biyela won a scholarship to study wine making. Now she's about to launch her own brand. More