NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) -- Criminal investigations, "phantom" recalls and executive oustings are exposing a dark side of Johnson & Johnson, once considered a pillar of American industry.
Here's the latest intrigue:
J&J's double whammy: First, lawmakers investigating J&J's (JNJ, Fortune 500) string of drug recalls announced a second hearing to ask executives to explain inconsistencies in testimony of what they knew about problems with drugs like Tylenol and Benadryl and why they were yanked off store shelves. Those over-the-counter drugs were made by the company's McNeil Consumer Healthcare unit.
Johnson & Johnson CEO William Weldon was invited to testify at the first hearing but he didn't appear due to illness. It'll be harder for him to give lawmakers the run around a second time. Colleen Goggins, chairman of Johnson & Johnson's global consumer products division, who stood in for Weldon in May, announced her retirement last Thursday.
However, Peter Luther, the president of the troubled McNeil division, is still employed by the company.
"Goggins' exit is worrisome. It's another black eye for Johnson & Johnson because she was touted as the next CEO of the company," said Damien Conover, analyst with Morningstar.
Secret recalls: Lawmakers unveiled documents in May that showed Johnson & Johnson hired contractors to conduct a clandestine recall of more than 88,000 Motrin tablets.
To conduct clandestine recalls products are removed from store shelves without notifying consumers of potential problems.
Johnson & Johnson has maintained that its executives never authorized such a broad based recall of Motrin but e-mails released last Thursday indicate that despite assertions to the contrary, Luther may have approved the "phantom" recall of Motrin.
On May 27, 2009, Luther writes to other McNeil executives and seems to be pushing the secret Motrin recall:
"Group, given our current financial situation, I hope we're not really going to double our cost to do this. Let's make this happen ASAP."
An email dated June 30, 2009, from WIS, a "phantom" recall subcontractor hired by Johnson & Johnson, indicates that the companies may have also been planning a secret recall of children's Tylenol and that Johnson & Johnson knew about problems with those drugs months before they were officially recalled.
"We are exploring another similar but potentially larger recall for July involving children's Tylenol. WIS will look to explore next week the potential quantities in 400 geographically dispersed stores to 'assess' the quantities on shelves ....this across mass, grocery, drug and convenience [stores]. (Wal-Mart is on the list.)"
"J&J could ask Inmar/WIS to move ahead on a scope to purchase product that would make our Motrin project look small." [Inmar and WIS are the contractors involved in the Motrin recall.]
Hits keep coming. Morningstar's Conover says the investigations are making Johnson & Johnson vulnerable on two fronts: Its bottomline and the reputation of its brands.
"The financial impact can be quantified but the hit to the brand is less quantifiable," he said. J&J has said that its recent drug recalls will cost the company $600 million in sales this year, or about 1% of J&J's total sales.
"J&J has three big groups. It's branded drugs, its consumer products division which includes McNeil and its medical device units. So when its OTC division keeps getting the black eyes, it hurts the entire reputation of the company," he said.
Johnson & Johnson's over-the-counter drugs are more dependent on brand image than any of its other products, Conover said.
More money is expected to be wagered on the Mayweather vs. Pacquiao showdown than on any other fight ever. More
The U.S. economy and markets have been flat this year. More
The 40-year-old Windows maker leaps into the future with augmented reality goggles. More
Limestone mines in the Midwest have been rehabilitated into commercial spaces with two big selling points: cheaper rent and lower energy bills. More
Most victims of workplace violence are women. Immigrants and Latinos are most likely to suffer fatal accidents at work. More