Our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy have changed.

By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to the new Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

Oil shock threatens airline recovery

By Aaron Smith, staff writer


NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- U.S. airlines had their best year in a decade in 2010, but with a mere 2% profit margin.

Now that razor-thin cushion is threatened by rising fuel prices -- and with it so is the industry's nascent recovery.

"While labor costs have been going down, fuel prices have been going up," said Frank Werner, a finance professor at Fordham University and a licensed pilot. "Fuel prices are now the highest cost for the airlines."

In recent days, travelers have started witnessing the industry's response.

Carriers have successfully increased airfares four times so far this year, exceeding the total number of airfare hikes for all of last year, according to Rick Seaney, chief executive of Farecompare.com. As a result, consumers are paying, on average, $40 more than they were at the end of 2010.

Seaney said that industry is currently attempting a fifth air fare hike. The recently-merged United Continental (UAL) added a fuel surcharge of $20 on Wednesday and American Airlines (UAL) matched the fare a few hours later, he said. If consumers are willing to pay these higher fares, then rival airlines have a strong incentive to follow suit.

"At this point, the carriers can pass through more gradual oil price increases to their customers," said Raymond Neidl, independent airline consultant. "Where the airlines would have a harder time adjusting [would be] a rapid increase in oil prices or high volatility due to unpredictable political developments."

An oil shock last hit carriers in 2008, when fuel prices spiked. But the recession stymied their success in increasing fares. So instead, they added ancillary fees for services that once came for free, like baggage check, curb-side check-in, pets, food and non-alcoholic drinks. Passengers griped but paid the fees anyway, resulting in billions of dollars in airline profits.

Airlines also cut capacity: They eliminated their least efficient flights to make sure that remaining flights were packed full so they wouldn't lose money on empty seats. On top of that, six carriers merged into three, lessening competition.

"The number of legacy carriers has declined by half in the last decade," said George Hoffer, transportation economist at University of Richmond in Virginia. "So it's much easier to coordinate price increases."

As a result, 2010 was the industry's most profitable year in a decade.

"But that's not saying much," said John Heimlich, chief economist with the Air Transport Association, noting that the industry's profit in 2010 was relatively modest 2%. "If we had to start with a 2% margin, we'll take it, but we're not going to stop with a 2%," he said.

The 2% profits equals about $4 billion worth of industry profits in 2010, but that follows an industrywide loss of $60 billion during the proceeding nine years, according to the ATA.

Airlines are now dealing with rising fuel prices, exasperated by the ongoing turmoil in Libya and other oil-producing countries, and the rising cost of refining oil into jet fuel.

Now, the industry faces a crossroads. Whether it fails or succeeds in 2011 depends upon two opposing factors: the strength of economic recovery versus the rise of fuel prices amid the political and economic mayhem that is roiling North Africa and the Middle East.

"I think what's going to happen is going to depend upon how long this Middle East crisis lasts and how long the U.S. economy continues to recover from this recession," said Werner. "The airlines are really hostages to the economic environment. When the economy goes south, one of the first things people cut is travel. Travel is a discretionary expense." To top of page

Search for Jobs

Index Last Change % Change
Dow 19,756.85 142.04 0.72%
Nasdaq 5,444.50 27.14 0.50%
S&P 500 2,259.53 13.34 0.59%
Treasuries 2.46 0.08 3.23%
Data as of 10:24pm ET
Company Price Change % Change
Bank of America Corp... 23.09 0.14 0.61%
Ford Motor Co 13.17 0.14 1.07%
Chesapeake Energy Co... 7.72 0.12 1.58%
Twenty-First Century... 28.21 -0.43 -1.50%
Apple Inc 113.95 1.83 1.63%
Data as of 4:15pm ET
Sponsors

Sections

Even Carl Icahn, one of President-elect Donald Trump's biggest cheerleaders on Wall Street, thinks the post-election exuberance in the stock market has gotten a bit out of hand. More

Republican leaders keep saying Obamacare is hurting the economy and killing jobs, but there's scant evidence for it. In fact, a number of studies show that the economy has been growing. More

Facebook admits it messed up more ad metrics than previously thought, potentially eroding its trust and relationship with marketers and publishers. More

The Los Angeles city attorney is suing four major retailers over claims that they deliberately inflated the original price on some items that misled customers into thinking they were getting a better deal. More