Payback: 82% to 87%
Cost: $10,000 to $13,000 for the typical house
When it makes sense: Your existing siding is visibly worn or has suffered damage (from a storm, for example).
Best way to do it: Choose traditional wood siding (such as redwood) or fiber cement, says Tim Carter, an experienced remodeler and founder of AsktheBuilder.com. Fiber-cement siding returns the most value for the money of any material, according to the Remodeling survey. It costs about 40% more than vinyl and requires painting from time to time, but it lasts for decades (in fact, many products come with a 50-year warranty).
Caveat: Getting prepainted siding, which Carter recommends because it saves on maintenance later, will add roughly 10% to the up-front price.
Cost-saving move: If only part of your siding is in bad shape - say, the south-facing wall - consider replacing only that portion and patching and painting the rest.
By Kate Ashford
NEXT: Get yourself a deck