Our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy have changed.

By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to the new Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

Money and Main Street
2 of 12
BACKNEXT
Why can't we split the money among taxpayers?
Why can't we split the money among taxpayers?
Colleen Hargis, 43, is a computer instructor at a local university.
Question: "I often hear, 'If they want to stimulate the economy, why don't they give every taxpayer $10,000?' People would buy cars, go on vacation, pay for college, buy TVs, etc. That sounds great to me. Would it work?" -- Colleen Hargis, Springfield, Mo.

Expert: Lakshman Achuthan, managing director, Economic Cycle Research Institute

Answer: "The government could give money to you or me, and that would create demand, which could be a very good way to break the recession. But you and I are not very confident about the economy, and if you think about what I'll do, there's a good chance I'm going to save it.

But the government is looking to have that money get spent and to have it multiplied somehow. Our economy is based on people spending money. So people saving money doesn't help.

For an individual, I would say it's a good idea to build up your savings and to tighten your belt, because there's so much uncertainty about how long the recession will last.

But the advice you give to policymakers when you want to revive the economy is to get people to spend money.

So I don't think that it would be a good idea to give everyone $10,000. That would preclude some very important triage from happening, such as funding unemployment insurance or getting state and local government financing needs met.

However, I would like the stimulus that comes out to have some support for households."

Expert: David Laibson, professor of economics, Harvard

Answer: "Some economists believe that transfers to individuals will not stimulate the economy, since the recipients will save a large fraction of those transfers. The evidence is mixed.

In the short-run (a few months) it is true that a large percentage of the transfer would be saved. However, over the next two years, low-income households would spend most of the transfer.

A stimulus package should include both government spending and household transfers, particularly transfers and tax cuts for low-income households."

NEXT: Give consumers debit cards instead of checks?
Last updated April 14 2009: 11:56 AM ET
More Galleries
Best-loved new cars of 2016 These cars are the most beloved among American drivers based on JD Power's annual survey of new vehicle buyers. More
This Indian university cranks out top-tier tech execs Many graduates from the Indian Institute of Technology have gone on to start and lead global tech companies. Here are a few of the most notable alums. More
Most valuable American car up for auction Carroll Shelby's own very first Shelby Cobra will be sold in August. It's almost certain to be the most valuable American car ever sold. More

Special Offer