Auto insurance: Picking an insurer
Find broad auto coverage without burning a hole in your pocket.
Cast a wide net.
First, check what's out there. Get quotes from at least four carriers. Try a free database such as InsWeb.
Try these options.
Companies like State Farm and USAA that deal directly with consumers without using independent agents are called "direct writers." In theory, they can pass on their savings by eliminating the middleman.
Let your state be your guide.
Insurance departments in 33 states and the District of Columbia offer online shopping guides for auto insurance. Your state's guide may identify little-known companies with competitive rates.
Look at service.
No discount in the world will make up for slow claims processing or shoddy repairs, so find out as much as you can about a company's service before you sign on.
Consumer Reports periodically publishes service ratings for large insurers. You can also ask a representative about a company's claims' turnaround time; a shorter turnaround is an indication of better service.
Focus on financials.
It's wise to look at the financial ratings of your auto insurer. Ask the company for that information, or check out one of the financial ratings services on the Web.
An A rating or higher from Standard & Poor's or an AA ranking or better from Moody's Investor Service is a good indicator of financial strength. Weiss Ratings, the most independent of the ratings services, and arguably the most stringent, posts a list of the currently weakest companies.
As a last resort, there's your state.
If your driving record is bad, you may initially have only one option other than taking public transportation: your state-sponsored high-risk pool and it's expensive.
If you must join the high-risk pool for now, try shopping again a year from now. Private insurers are always looking for new ways to serve more customers, and one company's black mark is another's business opportunity. Progressive Insurance, for instance, has thrived by insuring people and property that other carriers won't touch.