Hillary Clinton's stumble highlights campaign transparency problems

hillary clinton leaves chelsea clinton apartment
Hillary Clinton leaves the home of her daughter Chelsea Clinton, where she'd gone after having departed from a September 11 Commemoration Ceremony early.

Hillary Clinton's wobbly, stumbling exit from Sunday's September 11 commemoration set off a flurry of questions and concerns about the Democratic presidential nominee's health.

For the reporters who cover her, there was also frustration.

With less than sixty days until the election, neither Clinton nor Donald Trump has allowed for what's known as a "protective pool," a rotating group of reporters that travel with a candidate in order to provide a minute-to-minute account of their activities.

Without a protective pool, Clinton was able to leave the memorial site without reporters, travel to her daughter Chelsea Clinton's apartment without reporters, and leave New York City for her home in Chappaqua, New York, without reporters. That left Clinton's press pool scrambling to follow her around Manhattan and up to Chappaqua, always a step behind.

hillary clinton 911
Hillary Clinton leaves the September 11 Commemoration Ceremony at the National September 11 Memorial & Museum

"Sunday's events at the Sept. 11 memorial show the importance of having a group of reporters on standby, and close at hand, to cover the potential next president of the United States," Anne Gearan, the Washington Post political reporter and current chair of the Clinton press pool, told CNNMoney.

"It also shows what happens when the Clinton campaign fails to treat those reporters as a true protective pool, which would travel in the same Secret Service protected-motorcade to every place the candidate goes," Gearan said. "The pool was left behind when she abruptly left the memorial, and was not kept apprised of what was happening in real time."

Gearan said the pool did not believe that Trump's lack of a protective pool "should have bearing on Clinton."

Still, the lack of a protective pool for either candidate highlights the degree to which both Clinton and Trump have been able to keep reporters at bay and exercise greater control over media access than previous nominees. Indeed, Trump did not even announce in advance that he would attend the memorial.

hillary clinton 911
Hillary Clinton's early exit set off a flurry of questions and concerns about the Democratic presidential nominee's health.

It is rare for presidential candidates to get to September of an election year without a protective pool. In 2008, then-Sen. Barack Obama agreed to a protective pool in June, just weeks after he had secured the Democratic nomination. His opponent, Sen. John McCain, waited until the end of July.

In 2012, Mitt Romney waited until August, earning criticism from political reporters and the Obama campaign.

George W. Bush did wait until September of 2000 to take on a protective pool, however.

"I'm surprised it's mid-September, just a little more than 8 weeks before Election Day, and neither candidate has a protective pool," Robert Gibbs, the former White House press secretary for President Obama, wrote on Twitter.

"Protective pool isn't always easy for either candidate or press but there comes a point for each nominee when it must be part of daily life," he wrote.

Clinton campaign spokespeople did not immediately respond to a request for comment regarding the absence of a protective pool.


CNNMoney Sponsors