The Diesel Puzzle: High mileage, pollution problems
When you scanned our list of the
Best and Worst Gas Mileage Cars,
you might have noticed that diesel-powered cars weren't included.
A lot of you did notice and wrote to tell us about it. Well, in our
own defense, we did say we were considering only "gasoline-powered
vehicles." We stuck to cars you can drive into any filling station
anywhere and find fuel (which includes the gasoline/electric hybrids
topping the list.) Diesel fuel can be scarce at times, especially in
rural and center-city areas. Truck stops have it, of course. Along
main suburban highways, something like one in four big stations have
diesel pumps, estimates Darren Wight, editor-in-chief of the trade
paper National Petroleum News. He adds: "You may have to look
a little harder for fuel, but you're getting great mileage while you're looking."
The diesel versions of the Volkswagen Golf, Jetta and New Beetle, all
using the same engine, get an estimated 49 mpg on the highway with manual
transmission. And, at today's prices, diesel fuel costs about 25 percent
less than regular gasoline. These are great cars, too, with punchy acceleration
and not nearly the amount of noise or fumes as the diesels of the past.
You may have a hard time getting one, though. Calls to Volkswagen dealers
from customers looking for diesel-powered have surged right along with gas
prices. VW is the only company selling diesel passenger cars in the U.S.
today (Detroit produces just a few big diesel pickups) and they're already
selling all that Volkswagen has allocated for the U.S. market. Volkswagen's
production limitations and worldwide demand keep it from bringing in more
diesels. In Europe, with chronically high gas prices, nearly one-third of
all cars sold are diesels. But in the US, diesels suffer from an environmental
Catch-22. While they produce only small amounts of the global-warming gases
like carbon dioxide, diesels do spew soot and smog-forming nitrogen oxide.
Environmental regulations thus limit how many diesels a car company may sell.
Even tougher regulations are ahead, proposed by the EPA and defended by
environmental groups. But advancing technology and lower-sulfur diesel fuel
may let more diesels on American highways. "We see a very promising future
for a high-tech, high-mileage diesel engine with lower emissions," says
Volkswagen spokesman Tony Fouladpour.
Here's a look at VW's 2001 diesel darlings:
Volkswagen Golf TDI
The $16,195 GL diesel Golf adds $1,245 and 18 mpg on the highway over its
sibling gasoline-powered Golf. (There also is a more expensive $17,400 GLS
diesel version). And forget about those draggy, no-acceleration diesels of
the 1970s. This 1.9-liter, 90-horsepower turbocharged diesel gives you plenty
of torque for quick starts. Sportier to drive than much of the compact competition,
the hatchback Golf also has its practical side. A fold-down rear seat lets
you fit in luggage or sports gear. The Golf boasts five-star government crash
tests and gives you standard anti-lock brakes and side air bags.
Volkswagen Jetta TDI
The Jetta's got the trademark Volkswagen agility on twisting back roads
combined with a comfortable highway ride. With the same four-cylinder diesel
engine as the Golf, list price for the manual-transmission GL version is
$17,995. The GLS, with more standard features like cruise control, is $18,700.
The Jetta has a side-curtain protection system, a thin but strong airbag that
covers the side windows in the event of a crash, for both front and rear
passengers. In government crash tests, it got five stars for frontal crashes
and four stars for side impact. Like all Volkswagens, it has a 10-year
powertrain warranty.
Volkswagen New Beetle TDI
Even if you're not old enough to remember the old Beetle, this blast from
the past with a turbo-diesel engine is still pretty cool. The diesel comes
only with the GLS version of the Beetle, listing at $17,900 with manual
transmission. You get lots of standard features too, like an anti-theft alarm
and remote locking system. The Beetle was one of the first small cars to get
strong crash test ratings. It gets four stars in frontal crashes from the
government, but an even higher "best pick" rating in an independent insurance
industry test.
NEXT: Best cars 2001
>>
|