Controversy grows over Brian Williams' Iraq apology

Brian Williams recounts Iraq war story on 'Letterman'
Brian Williams recounts Iraq war story on 'Letterman'

Update: The pilot interviewed in this story, Rich Krell, is no longer standing by his account. In a text to CNNMoney Friday morning, Krell wrote: "The information I gave you was true based on my memories, but at this point I am questioning my memories." (full story)

If NBC and Brian Williams believed a Facebook post and an on-air apology were enough, they were wrong.

In the hours after Williams recanted a long-told story about an RPG attack in Iraq, rank and file employees at NBC News openly wondered whether he would be sanctioned -- or worse -- for the series of errors.

Some of the employees said they doubted that Williams made an innocent mistake and said he'd damaged the network's credibility as well as his own.

But most employees predicted that Williams' job was safe, and some cautioned against an overreaction to the misstatements. No disciplinary action against the anchor is expected.

The executives in charge of the news division have declined to comment, perhaps out of a reluctance to advance the story. And following his apology on Wednesday, Williams said nothing more about it on his Thursday night newscast.

Meanwhile, new details emerged about what exactly happened back in 2003 -- further clouding an already confusing tale. Here's what we know:

Williams says he made an innocent mistake: Brian Williams has been NBC's top news anchor for the past decade. Several times in recent years, he has said that he was aboard a U.S. Army helicopter when it was hit by a rocket-propelled grenade on one of the first days of the Iraq War in 2003.

He was actually aboard a different helicopter.

Last Friday, while honoring a veteran on "NBC Nightly News," Williams recounted how his helicopter was "forced down after being hit by an RPG."

He apologized on Wednesday's "NBC Nightly News" for that specific error -- "I made a mistake," he said -- but he did not address his broader series of misstatements in the past.

NBC's Brian Williams apologizes for Iraq attack story
NBC's Brian Williams apologizes for Iraq attack story

Williams' apology came after soldiers challenged his account on Facebook and the military newspaper Stars and Stripes began investigating. Stars and Stripes interviewed several crew members on the 159th Aviation Regiment's helicopter that actually was struck by the RPG, and they said "the NBC anchor was nowhere near that aircraft or two other Chinooks flying in the formation that took fire."

Stars and Stripes reported Wednesday that "Williams arrived in the area about an hour later on another helicopter after the other three had made an emergency landing, the crew members said."

Related: How Brian Williams' Iraq story changed

Helicopter pilot tells CNN Williams 'messed up': Rich Krell, who was piloting the Chinook that Williams was on, tells a different story than the crew members who spoke to Stars and Stripes.

"Some of things he's said are not true. But some of the things they're saying against him are not true either," said Krell, who spoke exclusively to CNN on Thursday morning.

UPDATE: Krell is no longer standing by this account. On Friday morning he told CNN: "I am questioning my memories." (full story)

Krell explained that, contrary to Williams' comments in the past, there were three helicopters flying in close formation, not four.

"One of the birds broke down, so we were a flight of three," Krell said. "We were hauling metal bridges."

Williams was in the back of Krell's aircraft along with three other NBC staffers. Krell referred to his Chinook as the "second bird" in the formation. The "first bird," right in front of the "second bird," was struck by the RPG.

Due to his seat in the back, Williams was most likely unable to witness the RPG attack, Krell said.

All three of the helicopters were hit by small arms fire, Krell said, supporting Williams' past claims about that.

"The bridge expansions we were hauling took most of the hits," Krell said.

The three Chinooks took evasive maneuvers. Krell's helicopter dropped off its payload, then met up with the other two about 45 minutes later. That may explain why the other crew members told Stars and Stripes that Williams arrived in the area later.

Krell said of Williams, "Yeah, he messed up some things and said some things he shouldn't have. I [first] heard it a few years ago. ... Actually one of my flight engineers said, 'Did you hear him say that? Wasn't he on our bird?'"

Krell didn't seem overly bothered by Williams' revisionist history -- he chalked it up to wartime theatrics. "After a while, with combat stories, you just go 'Whatever,'" he said.

Anger inside NBC about the 'fish tale': Others have called the RPG attack story "a fish tale," one that grew and grew over the years, to the point where Williams felt comfortable saying that he'd been aboard the Chinook that was struck by the RPG.

An NBC News spokeswoman said Thursday that the network stood by Williams' apology and had nothing further to say.

Williams is the face of NBC News and is beloved by many viewers. Last December he signed a new contract that extends almost through the end of the decade.

At the time, Williams said that it was akin to "reaffirming your vows."

Williams has many fans within the news division, but they were mostly silent on Thursday. Others within the news division, granted anonymity to speak freely about the situation, said there was widespread shock and disbelief about Williams' foggy-memory explanation. One correspondent called it "unreal."

Correspondents and producers with war zone experience seemed particularly perturbed.

"I don't know how you manage to begin to clean up from this, or if you even can," said one longtime employee. "He's in for a hell of a ride."

For much of the day, the hashtag #BrianWilliamsRemembers was trending on Twitter across the United States. Williams found himself the punchline of jokes.

Yet NBC executives seemed to conclude that they could stomach the criticism and continue to support Williams.


CNNMoney Sponsors