Trump's tough talk on China is about to run into hard reality

Trump slams China as currency manipulator
Trump slams China as currency manipulator

President Trump wants American companies to help reduce the country's huge trade deficit with China.

A week before he's due to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping in Florida, Trump set the stage for a tense encounter.

"The meeting next week with China will be a very difficult one in that we can no longer have massive trade deficits and job losses," he said Thursday. "American companies must be prepared to look at other alternatives."

Related: Trump executive orders aimed at trade abuses

Trump didn't elaborate. He's following those words up by signing two executive orders Friday aimed at combating foreign trade practices that the White House says are abusive.

But Trump is going to have a tough job getting what he wants. Here's why:

Trade deficits

The U.S. deficit with China is by far the biggest. For goods and services, it stood at $310 billion last year, down about 7% from 2015, according to U.S. government data.

Many experts say Trump is right that China isn't playing fair on trade. But some of them are unsettled by Trump's obsession with the trade balance as a way of summing up economic health.

One of the executive orders he's expected to sign Friday will initiate a large-scale review of the causes of the trade deficits the U.S. runs with some of its largest trading partners.

America's complicated, critical trade relations with China
America's complicated, critical trade relations with China

Related: Why a trade deficit isn't like losing money

It may find that the deficit is a sign of a strong economy. When the U.S. was growing at 4% a year in the late 1990s, its trade deficit got bigger as American consumers bought up goods from around the world. And during the global financial crisis, between 2007 and 2009, the U.S. trade deficit got smaller.

China says it's doing nothing wrong.

"China does not deliberately seek a trade surplus," Zheng Zeguang, a vice minister of foreign affairs, said at a briefing Friday. "As the Chinese economy continues to grow and transform, our domestic market will expand and our demand for goods and services from other countries, including the U.S., will increase."

Related: How Trump could make the trade deficit look worse

What can be done?

If Chinese consumers start saving less and spending more, then the trade balance could correct itself.

That's likely to take a very long time. Trump will want a quicker solution.

But if he wants American firms to make their goods somewhere other than China, there's no guarantee they'll bring their factories and jobs back to the U.S.

Related: The truth about trade, American jobs and Donald Trump

Asian countries like Vietnam already look more attractive for low-end manufacturing industries like clothing and footwear, given increases in Chinese labor costs in recent years.

Chinese factory owners prepare for Trump
Chinese factory owners prepare for Trump

Many U.S. brands -- including the shoe firm owned by Trump's daughter Ivanka -- still use Chinese suppliers. Producing more of those goods in the U.S. would create low-paying jobs, but it would also make them more expensive, pushing up the cost of living for Americans.

Rather than putting up big barriers to U.S. markets, as Trump threatened to do on the campaign trail, American companies operating in China would prefer the president to pressure the Chinese government to make its huge economy more open.

Related: Why it would be tough for Trump to bring jobs back from China

Many jobs won't come back

Trump has also frequently blamed China for job losses in the U.S.

Most experts agree that deepening economic ties between the two economies cost some American workers their jobs in recent decades. But there's debate about the size of the impact -- and the picture is not that simple.

trump vs china

Some analysts say that many of the jobs would have left the U.S. anyway because China's economy was opening up to the world at a time when American corporations were already looking to shift jobs to lower-wage countries.

Other changes, like automation and better technology, are judged to have played a bigger role than trade in the drop in U.S. manufacturing jobs.

-- Steven Jiang contributed to this report.

Personal Finance


CNNMoney Sponsors