Technology > Tech Biz
'Offshoring' meets its enemies
The president has signed a bill restricting offshore outsourcing, and the states are following suit.
January 28, 2004: 1:47 PM EST
By Eric Hellweg, CNN/Money contributing columnist

Sign up for the Tech Biz e-mail newsletter

NEW YORK (CNN/Money) - Opponents of offshore outsourcing enjoyed a small victory on Jan. 23, when President Bush signed the Omnibus Appropriations Bill into law. Tucked inside the complicated legislation was the Thomas-Voinovich amendment, which forbids certain segments of the government to use foreign companies when outsourcing some government work.

The amendment is limited in scope and duration (it sunsets after a year), but already factions on both sides of the contentious offshore outsourcing debate are girding for battle.

As I warned last year, offshore outsourcing will snowball into a major election issue this year.

Recently in Tech Biz
The impact of the MyDoom worm
Demand dividends!
One Cingular sensation?
Yahoo and Google's Cold War
Nothing compares to Yahoo!

At least 13 bills that would ban offshore outsourcing are now wending their way through various state legislatures. In a recent New York Times editorial, Bob Herbert warned readers to bone up on the subject.

The Washington Alliance of Technology Workers plans to rally its troops against offshore outsourcing during the presidential campaign, according to

And the Information Technology Association of America and TechNet -- two influential Washington, D.C., tech lobbying groups -- have come out in opposition to the Thomas-Voinovich amendment. "The president signed the bill quietly, without ceremony, on Friday," says Olga Grkavac, a spokeswoman for the ITAA. "It sets an unfortunate precedent."

The impact on stocks

Tech investors need to assess their own positions on offshore outsourcing, check their portfolio companies, and monitor the news for developments.

More on offshoring
These jobs are never coming back
Guess which jobs are going offshore

Some companies, such as Dell, took a hit last year when quality-control issues arose from their offshore outsourcing, but Wall Street in general is very bullish on the topic, rewarding companies that announce offshore outsourcing plans.

The three leading Indian firms that benefit from U.S. outsourcing, Infosys, Wipro, and Satyam, have not yet seen their stock prices suffer as a result of Thomas-Voinovich or the building political opposition to offshoring. Both Infosys and Wipro, in fact, are trading near their 52-week highs.

So what do I think of the various anti-offshoring bills? When data-security issues are involved, I think keeping a task in the United States makes sense.

However, what we're seeing in these bills is largely a reaction to job loss. It's a sticky subject, for sure, not least because we're talking about sending white-collar -- not manufacturing and blue-collar -- jobs overseas.

So far, the politicians don't know quite how to handle the subject. Not to pick on him, but the approach taken thus far by Sen. John Kerry, the only Democratic candidate who's really spoken on the issue, is just plain silly.


In November, Kerry introduced the Call Center Consumer's Right to Know Act, which would require a call center to identify its location at the commencement of a call. As if someone needing emergency tech support would hang up if the service technician said she was sitting in Bangalore!

I see offshoring continuing to build momentum, and I think that, as a country, we need to respond in the way we always have: by innovating at the top end of the chain, not by drafting reactionary protectionist legislation.

Follow the news that matters to you. Create your own alert to be notified on topics you're interested in.

Or, visit Popular Alerts for suggestions.

"Whether it's the cotton gin or the Internet, we've added value by innovating," says Rick White, CEO of TechNet. "Innovation and free trade have served us very well."

The trouble arises on two fronts: First, there's not enough room left on the chain for us to ascend much further. And second, we're failing in the educational effort needed to train our future generations of workers.

What do you think? Drop me a line at and maybe I'll use your response in a future column.

Sign up to receive the Tech Biz column by e-mail.

Plus, see more tech commentary and get the latest tech news.  Top of page

UK security officials warn of 'new risks' from Huawei
Samsung or Xiaomi? It's a two-horse race for India's smartphone market
WhatsApp is adding new restrictions as killings continue in India
Is the era of easy money over?
Sergio Marchionne stepping down as CEO of Fiat Chrysler
A transatlantic trade war is brewing. Can it be stopped?

graphic graphic