Zocor losing patent protection
Merck and Pfizer stand to lose billions in sales as two of their biggest drugs, Zocor and Zoloft, go off patent.
NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) - Two of the biggest blockbuster drugs from the two biggest drugmakers in America are losing patent protection this month, setting the stage for a multi-billion dollar sales vacuum.
The two Zs - Zocor from Merck and Zoloft from Pfizer - are among the most recognizable names in Big Pharma. Merck's patent for Zocor, a cholesterol-cutting drug that totaled $4.4 billion in 2005 sales, expires Friday.
Pfizer's antidepressant Zoloft, with $3.3 billion in 2005 sales, loses patent protection next week, on June 30.
But analysts don't expect to see a big dip in the stock price for either company. Since both Merck and Pfizer have had many years to prepare for these patent expirations, the impending loss of sales is already baked into their stocks, analysts say.
To appease investors and take some of the sting out of this impending sales vacuum, Pfizer and Merck have both launched multi-billion dollar cost-cutting efforts and have begun courting biotechs in their effort to boost their new-drug pipelines.
When a brand name drug loses its patent, both the price of the drug and the dollar value of its sales each tend to drop about 80 percent over the next year, as competition opens to a host of generic drugmakers.
The original drugmakers often continue to produce the branded drugs regardless, because hundreds of millions of dollars in annual sales can still be gleaned from patients who prefer the brand name. But the real winners are patients and insurers, who pay much lower prices.
Simvastatin, the generic form of Zocor, will be produced by Teva Pharmaceuticals (up $0.82 to $32.07, Charts), the Israel-based market leader in generic drugs, and Ranbaxy Labs of India. On Friday, the Food and Drug Administration approved generic versions of Zocor from these two companies. As determined in patient litigation, they will be permitted to produce the drug for six months before the market opens up to other manufacturers. Teva will produce the generic through its subsidiary Ivax.
Swiss drug giant Novartis (up $0.51 to $52.80, Charts) tried to get into the action earlier by requesting a temporary restraining order against Teva and Ranbaxy, but a U.S. District Court judge in Washington shot down the request Friday.
"We are disappointed that our request for a temporary restraint order was denied, which now limits the generic market for simvastatin to two companies," said Kurt Leidner, spokesman for the Novartis unit Sandoz, the intended producer of simvastatin.
Generally, for the first six months after a patent expires, only one drug maker is allowed to produce the generic version in addition to the original manufacturer. But in this unusual case, Teva and Ranbaxy have both been permitted to produce simvastatin.
The FDA insists that generics work identically to brand-names. Nonetheless, some patients will never believe that generic simvastatin is the same as Zocor, or that generic sertraline is the same as Zoloft. Direct-to-consumer advertising and brand-name recognition all play a role in this kind of product loyalty.
Also, Big Pharma can continue to make money by introducing spin-offs of their branded drugs with tweaked indications, adding suffixes like XR (like the Wyeth antidepressant EffexorXR) or XL (as in the Forest Labs' antidepressant WellbutrinXL) to the original name to reflect an improvement.
In these patent-protected "extended release" versions, for instance, the new drugs can be taken less often than the original one, so they're marketed as being more convenient than their generic competitors. This allows the brand-name drugmakers to maintain some of their sales in the face of generic competition.
Jon LeCroy, analyst for Natexis Bleichroeder, said that Pfizer's Zoloft sales will be "decimated" by generic competition, but that this won't come as a surprise to investors. But Merck is still expected to aggressively market Zocor against the generic versions that Teva and Ranbaxy are preparing.
In addition, Merck spokeswoman Janet Skidmore said that its combination drug Vytorin, comprised of Zocor and Schering-Plough's (up $0.01 to $19.18, Charts) Zetia, should help it maintain a competitive edge in the cholesterol market. The two partners produce and market the drug through a separate company, Merck/Schering-Plough Pharmaceuticals.
Zocor's patent loss may also threaten sales of Pfizer's Lipitor, another cholesterol-cutting drug which could face competition from generic Zocor. Lipitor is the world's top-selling drug with $12.2 billion in 2005 sales.
"The managed care plans are already encouraging people to use Zocor over Lipitor," said LeCroy, though he added that the issue is complex and it's difficult to project what will happen with Lipitor sales.
Pfizer, and also some analysts, have insisted that Lipitor is not interchangeable with competing products like Zocor. Pfizer is also looking to defend this space by testing Lipitor, which lowers LDL or "bad" cholesterol, in combination with the experimental drug torcetrapib, which appears to raise HDL, or "good" cholesterol. According to some analysts, this combination could add billions of dollars in potential sales, if the tests are successful and the drug is FDA-approved.
LeCroy does not own shares of Pfizer or Merck stock.