Retirement plan interrupted

This 31-year-old psychologist can't let a costly mortgage stop her from saving

Subscribe to Personal Finance
google my aol my msn my yahoo! netvibes
Paste this link into your favorite RSS desktop reader
See all RSS FEEDS (close)
By Asa Fitch, Money Magazine reporter

Patty Marquez

NEW YORK (Money Magazine) -- When Patty Marquez graduated from the University of Minnesota more than five years ago and moved to Southern California, she thought about buying a house.

But with prices already sky-high in the Southland market, "I was scared," says Marquez, now 31. So she rented for more than four years.

But all along, even as prices in the region continued to climb, she kept thinking to herself: Isn't owning a home the right thing to do? Last February the school psychologist, who now makes $77,000 a year, took the plunge and purchased a $600,000 duplex, putting 3 percent down on a 40-year fixed-rate mortgage.

Though prices started to ease by the time she bought, her timing was still poor. Since Marquez bought the property in Signal Hill, Calif., just north of Long Beach, home values in her area have fallen more than 3 percent, and they're expected to drop an additional 9 percent in 2008.

Becoming a homeowner hurt her net worth in more ways than one. After she bought the duplex, Marquez's monthly housing expenses jumped from about $850 when she rented to $3,000. Even with the money she earns renting out a portion of her home, her net housing expenses have more than doubled.

As a result, Marquez stopped contributing to her 403(b) retirement plan. So after getting off to a good start - she already has $65,000 saved up in her tax-deferred account - Marquez wonders if her house is mortgaging her future. "I don't want to put a halt to saving," she says, "but I won't be able to save as much as before."

Where she is now

The most important element in her financial life is her mortgage. It is the $582,000 elephant in the room that she can't ignore. In order to afford it, Marquez had to stretch her loan out to 40 years, fixed at 5.1 percent, with the first 10 years being interest-only.

The longer term means she'll build equity in her home at a slower pace. And during the initial interest-only phase, she won't build any equity at all. Plus, once this period ends, her total monthly payments will jump to nearly $4,000, which will make it that much harder to afford her home while saving for retirement.

What she should do

There's no easy way out of this bind, says Sandra Field, a financial planner in Los Alamitos, Calif. If Marquez were to sell now, she might not get enough to pay off her mortgage. Still, creative thinking can help buy Marquez some breathing room, Field says.

Squeeze more income from her property. Marquez currently rents out half of her duplex, charging $1,100 a month. A longtime renter herself, Marquez says she's reluctant to jack up that price. "I just don't want to do that to my tenant," she says. But Field points out that not only is her renter paying below-market prices, but he's been paying virtually the same rent for the past five years.

So "he must have expected a significant increase with a new owner," Field says. She suggests Marquez raise the rent to $1,400 in early 2008 and then continue hiking it by $50 every year. The rising rental income should give her some financial flexibility during the interest-only phase of her loan and help cover some of her costs when her payments jump after that period ends.

Restart her 403(b) contributions. Ideally, Marquez should be saving around 12% of her salary each year, says Field. And until recently, Marquez was saving more than that - about $10,000 to $15,000 a year. Though she stopped contributing to her 403(b), Marquez says she could probably scrape together $4,000 a year to put into the account. Field says even a small amount helps. And if Marquez raises her rent, that should free up another $3,000 to $4,000 for her 403(b).

Tweak the investment mix. With fewer dollars going into her retirement plan, Marquez needs to be more mindful of the money she already has in her account. Field thinks Marquez's nest egg is too heavily tilted toward large-cap U.S. stock funds like Van Kampen Comstock (ACSTX). Marquez chose Van Kampen to manage her 403(b), but Field says the Van Kampen choices within her plan don't offer her a good small-cap option.

So she advises Marquez to switch her provider to Fidelity. That way, as she revamps her portfolio, Marquez will have a broader range of funds to choose from, such as Fidelity Small Cap Stock (FSLCX) and Fidelity Diversified International (FDIVX).

"This is a transitional period for me," Marquez says. "There's a lot of change, but I'm hoping to find my way through."

WANT A MONEY MAKEOVER? E-mail us at makeover@moneymail.comTo top of page

Photo Galleries
17 cool gadgets that tease the future Smart telescopes, surveillance for dogs, an electric roadster and more from CES 2018. More
These 12 airplane beds let you really sleep on a flight For the price of a premium class ticket, you may just get a space that's comfortable, private, and quiet enough to ensure a good rest. More
CES 2018 kicks off with oddball gadgets The biggest tech show of the year opened with a collection of quirky gadgets. More