Carl Icahn (pg. 2)

By Shawn Tully, Fortune editor-at-large

That leaves AREP with more than $4 billion in cash available for new investments. What will Icahn do with the money? A favorite area is the beleaguered auto-parts business. Icahn is bidding to buy industry giant Lear for $2.8 billion. In the hedge fund, he's also making a foray into Florida condominiums, of all benighted areas, via a 20% stake in luxury developer WCI, which has put itself up for sale to avoid his clutches. The fund recently took a $133 million stake in Anadarko Petroleum (Charts, Fortune 500), the company that bought Kerr-McGee. Though Icahn won't comment, he probably reckons that Anadarko's lagging share price doesn't reflect the value of its reserves.

Of course, Icahn also encounters failure. His most notable so far is Blockbuster (Charts, Fortune 500), a stock that has languished for the 2 1/2 years he has owned it. But those failures also show another side of Icahn: the dedicated director fighting to improve operations (Blockbuster) and the outside agitator pledging to be the shareholders' watchdog (Motorola). "We never supported Icahn in a proxy battle until he served two tough years on the Blockbuster board and saved shareholders tens of millions in that role," says Chris Young of ISS.

Screaming buys

Icahn's biggest strength isn't his agility in proxy fights, but what comes first: his knack for picking targets. His skill at prospecting is so well honed that in most cases he's destined to make money from the day he buys the shares. Then it's a matter of squeezing management to sweeten the inevitable gains.

Put simply, Icahn looks for companies that are screaming buys, meaning that the value of their assets far exceeds the total value of their shares, or market cap. In general he looks for "hard assets" like real estate, oil reserves, and timberland that are relatively easy to value and resell, and avoids tech companies that depend heavily on developing new products. But not always. Icahn has developed expertise in pharmaceuticals, where he feels that costs are far too high and the value of pipeline drugs is often drastically underestimated.

He's the contrarian to end all contrarians. "A lot of people bet against trends, but Carl goes beyond that," says Ken Moelis, chief of investment banking at UBS. "He'll buy at the worst possible moment, when there's no reason to see a sunny side and no one agrees with him." Explains Icahn: "The consensus thinking is generally wrong. If you go with a trend, the momentum always falls apart on you. So I buy companies that are not glamorous and usually out of favor. It's even better if the whole industry is out of favor."

To make his picks, Icahn surrounds himself with a crack team at his Manhattan headquarters. They perform other functions as well, like negotiating inexpensive bulk contracts for everything from computers to insurance and making them available to the companies Icahn controls. "I use my guys to watch purchasing the way King William used Captain Kidd to watch the pirates," says Icahn.

But the top job is finding candidates to buy. His two top dealmakers and prospectors are Keith Meister and Vince Intrieri. Meister, a gregarious 34-year-old with a Kojak-clean pate, is a veteran of private-equity firm Northstar Capital Partners who serves as CEO of AREP. Intrieri, 50, is an intense, soft-spoken CPA who specializes in bankruptcy workouts. Both are finely attuned to the boss's taste in bargains.

The staff of 26 professionals includes an in-house law firm of nine attorneys. Intrieri and Meister regularly scan the Bloomberg databases for what Intrieri calls "asset-rich companies that are undervalued," especially ones with lots of cash as a percentage of their market cap. It was the big cash position coupled with the tumbling share price that alerted the staff to Motorola.

The most prolific source of candidates is Icahn himself. "From 50% to 60% of the ideas come from Carl," says Intrieri. Icahn is on the phone as much as ten hours a day, grilling investment bankers, hedge fund managers, analysts, and anyone else who might have a lead. Once he's picked a candidate, Icahn discusses every aspect of the investment, over and over, with his staff. He doesn't like memos, nor does he use e-mail. The entire process is verbal. "It's an iterative process with Carl," says Meister. When he's doing a deal Icahn draws on his philosophy training to probe his associates. "You'll say blue is blue, and he'll say it's yellow just to be a contrarian," says Meister. "Then he'll make you convince him it's blue." His staff says that he reminds them of the seemingly befuddled TV detective Columbo.

Icahn is a night owl. His business day begins in midmorning, when he starts making calls from the terrace of his duplex apartment in the Museum Tower on West 53rd Street. His real work starts when he arrives at the office in early afternoon; it's then that he puts his staff through his barrage of questions about candidates for investment. Around 8 P.M. Icahn goes out to dinner, often accompanied by members of his staff. His canteen is Il Tinello, a tony Italian restaurant whose menu features Pasta alla Icahn - farfalle with a sauce of tomato, onion, and bacon. After dinner Icahn returns home and often holds conference calls with his lawyers and other aides that can run from 11 P.M. to 1:30 A.M. What drives the billionaire to stay on the phone in the middle of the night? Intrieri once asked that question during a marathon call. After a long pause Icahn shot back, "Why do you play golf?"

Icahn's personality is a blend of the relentless and the quirky. This billionaire regularly appears in the office in chinos, boat shoes, and a braid belt, with two pairs of glasses entwined around his neck. Scribbling on a yellow notepad, his hair matted down, he resembles a mad professor.

A conversation with Icahn is a wild ride. He'll start by saying how former Paramount chief Martin Davis warned him never to invest in a movie, veer into a description of how he pays performance bonuses to the principal and teachers who work at the charter school he supports in the South Bronx, and finish with an anecdote about a seriocomic encounter with the president of South Korean tobacco company KT&G, one of the hedge fund's major investments. Icahn recalls that he kept making requests, the translator kept laboriously translating them, and the president kept dismissing them with a clipped "No!" Finally, Icahn grabbed the president for a private conference, muddling along in English without the translator, and lo and behold, they got to like each other, reaching agreement on a host of topics. "We walked out and he gave me a high-five!" raves Icahn. "And he's a lot shorter than I am!"

On Thursday evenings Icahn and his wife, Gail, the former assistant whom the divorced Icahn wed in 1999, drive to their beachfront home in East Hampton in a Lexus SUV. She's at the wheel but forbids him to use his cellphone, so they listen to books on tape. (Recent choice: "The Kite Runner," the bestselling novel about an Afghan boy.) In East Hampton they unwind by singing old show tunes after dinner with friends. "We'll waltz down the hallway singing 'On the Road to Mandalay,'" says Gail, who dubs her husband "Cineplex" because he juggles so many deals.

Their favorite pastime is tennis. Gail says Icahn is so aggressive that playing him is like suffering through "the Bataan death march." Icahn does a standup comedy routine at hedge fund dinners in exchange for donations to his charities. One of his favorite jokes: "A thief stole my wife's credit card, but I didn't report it. Guess why? The thief spends less than my wife!"

Icahn can be brutally tough in business meetings, where he's known for hurling epithets ranging from "You'll never work on Wall Street again" to "That's the dumbest thing I ever heard." "He uses a lot of crude, abusive language," says Ross. He's also famous for mangling names to hilarious effect, and adversaries swear the practice is intentional. "When I disagreed with him, he'd call me 'Mollusk,'" recalls Moelis. "You always get a show with Carl."

If Icahn aspires to being something of a populist today, the makeover would have been an even bigger reach in the past. Besides the greenmailing that left regular shareholders in the cold, his tenure as owner-operator of TWA from 1985 to 1993 no doubt cost many workers their jobs after he stripped the airline of many of its most profitable assets and starved it of new spending on planes and equipment.

The chief criticisms of Icahn today: His fierce attacks sometimes hurt the effectiveness of targeted CEOs who don't deserve it, and sometimes his quick fixes are wrong for the situation. "He puts the fear of God in management and gets them to do what he wants," says a prominent investor. "It might be a quick shot in the arm for the stock but might not be in the best long-term interests of the company."

A case in point is Time Warner. Early last year Icahn pushed for a big share buyback and championed breaking up the media giant into four separate companies. The buyback turned out to be effective, but the breakup idea didn't convince Wall Street that the parts were worth more individually than as units of Time Warner. "We got tepid backing from institutions," says Rosenstein, whose fund endorsed Icahn's plan. Yet the Time Warner excursion is a classic case of how Icahn wins by losing - all the way to the bank. His coup was recognizing that Time Warner was cheap. Though his attack failed, it barely mattered. The stock rose $4, to $21.50.

On Motorola, Icahn is counting on a similar insight. Quite simply, Icahn sees Motorola as a bargain and is confident that management must either fix the cellphone business or depart. "The proxy fight focused the board and management on the fact that they have a major problem that must be fixed," he asserts. "And they don't have a long time to fix it."

Icahn isn't even particularly upset that he lost the election. "It's not great to be in a minority position," he admits. "It's like being in midcourt in tennis. It's often better to be outside, where you can buy more stock or launch a tender offer." Meister reckons that Motorola, with a market cap of $42 billion, presents a compelling opportunity now that the market is valuing its huge cellphone business at just $10 billion. If the business is revived, Meister estimates it will be worth $25 billion, driving Motorola's stock up by around 35%.

Icahn says he wishes Zander well. "If he fixes it, no one will be happier than me," says Icahn. "I'm a nice guy. I stay friends with guys like Zander despite all the fighting." Zander told Fortune his conversations with Icahn have been "engaging and constructive."

To his credit, Icahn is waging a limited but highly effective war against bloated CEO pay. His most notable battleground is Blockbuster. Icahn was appalled that CEO John Antioco's package called for a golden parachute of more than $20 million. He was also irritated that Antioco stood to make a $6.5 million bonus for 2006 with Blockbuster stock in the dumps.

Icahn assigned his lawyers to study the contract and discovered that the board had "negative discretion," meaning it could cancel or reduce any bonus. So this year, at Icahn's request, the board chose him personally to bargain down the pay package for Antioco, who was pledging to leave at the end of 2007. Icahn called him at home on a Friday night. "I'd had two margaritas, and Carl sounded like he'd had a martini," recalls Antioco. "He said, 'Your bonus could be zero!' I said I'd arbitrate. Carl said, 'You'll lose in arbitration!'" But the next day they reached an amicable settlement that cut Antioco's bonus and severance payment from what could have been more than $30 million to just $8 million.

"It was painful," says Antioco, "but Carl and I will stay friends. He calls me 'Jawn,' and I had the Pasta alla Icahn." Antioco says he wouldn't even rule out working for an Icahn venture someday. Might not be all fun, he implies, but it sure would be a moneymaker.

Research associates: Doris Burke and Marilyn Adamo Top of page

previous
Sponsors
Market indexes are shown in real time, except for the DJIA, which is delayed by two minutes. All times are ET. Disclaimer LIBOR Warning: Neither BBA Enterprises Limited, nor the BBA LIBOR Contributor Banks, nor Reuters, can be held liable for any irregularity or inaccuracy of BBA LIBOR. Disclaimer. Morningstar: © 2014 Morningstar, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer The Dow Jones IndexesSM are proprietary to and distributed by Dow Jones & Company, Inc. and have been licensed for use. All content of the Dow Jones IndexesSM © 2014 is proprietary to Dow Jones & Company, Inc. Chicago Mercantile Association. The market data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved. FactSet Research Systems Inc. 2014. All rights reserved. Most stock quote data provided by BATS.
Market indexes are shown in real time, except for the DJIA, which is delayed by two minutes. All times are ET. Disclaimer LIBOR Warning: Neither BBA Enterprises Limited, nor the BBA LIBOR Contributor Banks, nor Reuters, can be held liable for any irregularity or inaccuracy of BBA LIBOR. Disclaimer. Morningstar: © 2014 Morningstar, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer The Dow Jones IndexesSM are proprietary to and distributed by Dow Jones & Company, Inc. and have been licensed for use. All content of the Dow Jones IndexesSM © 2014 is proprietary to Dow Jones & Company, Inc. Chicago Mercantile Association. The market data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved. FactSet Research Systems Inc. 2014. All rights reserved. Most stock quote data provided by BATS.