(Money Magazine) -- Does any lawn-care implement inspire more controversy and vitriol than the leaf blower?

Proponents say it's efficient and saves them from doing backbreaking work. Detractors argue that blowers are noisy and that raking brings satisfaction.

Powerful. Surprisingly quiet. The Stihl BR 500 Backpack Blower scores an A -.

More from Money Magazine Correcting your credit report gets easier Cut your cooling costs by 30% or more After Obamacare's launch, a look ahead Best Places to Live Current Issue Subscribe to Money

To which we say: satisfaction? Maybe, but clearing your lawn in minutes and still being physically able to throw a football around with your kids while your neighbor throws his back out and blisters his hands - that's pretty satisfying too.

Choosing a leaf blower is, in fact, the most strenuous part of the chore. For example, some models are gas-powered and some are electric.

Gas blowers require you to keep fuel handy, but they generally deliver more power (and perhaps more noise - more on that in a moment).

Electric ones are easy to operate, but with the exception of battery-powered models, you have to remain tethered to a power cord.

Then there's style. If you have a small yard, a handheld will do. Bigger yard and more trees? Consider a powerful backpack blower.

Now, about the noise. Many towns limit the use of blowers because of it, and even if yours doesn't, you'll want to avoid gripes from neighbors. A wave of new blowers promise to limit the noise without compromising on power, mostly thanks to innovations like widening a section of the blower tube, which acts as a muffler, and adding more insulation around the engine. (If your neighbor still complains, offer to do his lawn. Shouldn't take long.)

The final issue is price. Your average rake costs about as much as a couple of movie tickets. The most expensive home leaf blowers - namely, gas-powered backpack models - can run as much as $500. But cheaper options, especially electric models, cost as little as $70.

I turned my lawn into a testing ground for five blowers: three gas, two electric.

To gauge power, I unleashed them not just on foliage but on a stack of bricks. To measure noise, I enlisted - who else? - my neighbors.

Electric, $86

Pros: Quietest and lightest (7.3 lbs.) of the bunch. Comes with vacuum/ mulching attachment (with leaf bag).

Cons: Not very powerful; the bricks barely budged. Difficult to comfortably position leaf bag when vacuuming.

Bottom Line: This model proves there's a direct correlation between power and noise: If you want something really quiet, you're going to sacrifice a degree of brawniness.But it's okay for smaller yards.

Grade: B -

Electric, $88

Pros: Not the lightest of those tested, but not bad: 8.1 lbs. Noise isn't excessive. Comes with easy vacuum attachment(with leaf bag)

Cons: Not particularly powerful or compact. Like many electric models, requires a power cord.

Bottom Line: For small to mid-size yards, this handheld is pretty good - provided you don't mind the cord (you get used to it). It couldn't topple bricks, but it did okay on leaves. Also good for blowing dust from a garage or patio.

Grade: B +

Gas, $450

Pros: Powerful (it had no problem with the bricks) but plenty streamlined too. Sleek styling makes it easy to move in tight spots.

Cons: Say what? Neighbors could barely tolerate the highpitched whirring. Requires that you mix fuel and oil.

Bottom Line: If you don't live too close to your neighbors, this might be a better bet than the Stihl. And though it's heavier (at 22.5 lbs.), it actually feels lighter thanks to its backfriendly design. But it sure is loud.

Grade: B

Gas, $219

Pros: Compact, easy to store and almost as light (9.6 lbs.) as electric models. Doesn't require a gas-andoil mixlike some gas models.

Cons: Bad combo: It's both noisy and weak - neighbors complained, and the bricks remained standing. Start-up is cumbersome.

Bottom Line: Less powerful than the gas backpacks tested and noisier than the electrics, though it can move leaves. Unless you swear by the Deere name, consider one with less noise and more oomph.

Grade: C

Gas, $470

Pros: Packs a punch. The bricks didn't stand a chance. Surprisingly quiet for a heavy-duty gas blower.

Cons: Backpack models can be bulky and difficult to strap on, and this is no exception. Weighs in at 21.8 lbs. Requires a gas-and-oil mix.

Bottom Line: For large yards, this is the blower to buy. The design won't win any awards - it reminded one friend of a potato gun - but you're blowing leaves, not making a fashion statement.

Grade: A -