Breaking Views

Too little, too late for AIG

The government can't seem to find an alternative to throwing good taxpayer money after bad.

By Lauren Silva Laughlin, breakingviews.com
March 2, 2009: 11:05 AM ET

(breakingviews.com) -- American International Group has set a doleful record. The insurer has reported a $61.7 billion quarterly loss, the largest ever. The swelling of its woes also makes U.S. taxpayers even bigger losers.

Now the group is subject to yet another government rescue. The basic idea seems to be that the insurer pays less to get more. The interest rate on AIG's credit line from the government is to be lowered closer to Libor, from three percentage points over Libor.

The package also includes $30 billion of preferred shares, which will not pay a coupon in the first instance. Meanwhile, AIG's interest bill on its existing prefs will fall by $4 billion.

Regulators can't see any realistic alternative to having taxpayers throw good money after bad. The authorities may not be completely sure that an AIG (AIG, Fortune 500) failure would cause market mayhem. But after the chaos ignited by the Lehman Brothers' bankruptcy, they cannot take the chance.

Still, six months after the initial bailout of AIG, it is disappointing that so little had been done to reduce the risk of failure. The government, which after all effectively controls AIG, could have spent the time aggressively unwinding AIG's positions and reducing its exposures. A separation of the insurer into good and bad - now on the agenda - could have been completed by now.

It ought not to have been too late for some of the pain to be shared. Minority shareholders' continuing stake is a fig leaf to cover over the shame - and government liabilities - which would come with outright nationalization. That's lame politics, and costly for taxpayers.

AIG's creditors could also have taken a haircut. Of course, that would amount to a default, with troublesome implications of its own. But the U.S. government should be rethinking its assumption, shown most recently with Citigroup (C, Fortune 500), that taxpayers must be ready to bail out sacrosanct creditors.

Of course, the law provides no easy path for rescuing this huge, failing financial institution. But taxpayers have been let down in recent months by inadequate efforts to keep the black hole of AIG from expanding at their expense. To top of page


Company Price Change % Change
Bank of America Corp... 22.63 0.58 2.63%
Ford Motor Co 12.41 0.00 0.00%
Chesapeake Energy Co... 6.98 -0.03 -0.43%
Citigroup Inc 57.39 -0.99 -1.70%
Reynolds American In... 58.00 0.32 0.55%
Data as of Jan 18
Index Last Change % Change
Dow 19,804.72 -22.05 -0.11%
Nasdaq 5,555.66 16.93 0.31%
S&P 500 2,271.89 4.00 0.18%
Treasuries 2.39 0.06 2.66%
Data as of 8:01am ET
More Galleries
The Obama economy in 10 charts President Obama came to office in January 2009 in the midst of the Great Recession. Much has turned around since then, but he's been criticized for a slow recovery. More
Best Jobs in America CNNMoney/PayScale's top 100 careers with big growth, great pay and satisfying work. More
Top-paying jobs Anesthesiologists take home a median $335,000 in salary and bonus annually. What other great careers from CNNMoney and PayScale.com's list of Best Jobs in America offer hefty paychecks? More
Sponsors