Our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy have changed.

By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to the new Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

5 of 12
BACK NEXT
Winner: Toyota Prius
Cost: $24,170
Fuel economy (CR test): 44 mpg
Total 5-year savings: $2,000

Despite its high fuel economy, the Prius ranks relatively low in Consumer Reports' analysis in part because the magazine compared the Prius to the Toyota Corolla compact car. (In all other cases, the vehicles were compared with versions without the hybrid system, but there is no non-hybrid Prius.)

While the Prius' exterior is similar in size to the Corolla, its interior dimensions are actually closer to the Toyota Camry mid-size car, so it might also be valid to compare the Prius to that car as well.

If it was compared with the Camry, which costs more and gets lower fuel economy than the Corolla, the Prius would have ranked at the top of this list by a wide margin. Total five-year savings, according to Consumer Reports' figures, would be about $10,000.

But Consumer Reports says that it finds the recently redesigned Corolla, which is larger and offer more amenities than the old version, to be a more fitting comparison.

NEXT: Winner: Chevrolet Malibu Hybrid

Last updated September 03 2008: 11:51 AM ET
More Galleries
Best-loved new cars of 2016 These cars are the most beloved among American drivers based on JD Power's annual survey of new vehicle buyers. More
This Indian university cranks out top-tier tech execs Many graduates from the Indian Institute of Technology have gone on to start and lead global tech companies. Here are a few of the most notable alums. More
Most valuable American car up for auction Carroll Shelby's own very first Shelby Cobra will be sold in August. It's almost certain to be the most valuable American car ever sold. More

Special Offer