Why are ETFs more tax-efficient?

By Walter Updegrave, CNN/Money contributing columnist


NEW YORK (CNN/Money) -- Question: I've been reading about Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), but don't understand why ETFs are supposed to be more tax efficient when investors redeem shares. Doesn't the ETF manager have to sell securities to pay departing shareholders the same as a mutual fund manager does? And if those selling those shares results in a net realized capital gain wouldn't that mean the ETF would has to pass along that taxable gains to shareholders just like a mutual fund? -- reader in Illinois

Answer: Your question gets to the fundamental difference between ETFs and mutual funds. As I explain in a series of articles in our ETF Center, ETFs trade on an exchange like stocks, which means you're typically buying shares from an investor who already owns them or selling shares you own to an investor who wants to own ETFs.

walter_updegrave_new.03.jpg

In such cases, the ETF doesn't get involved in the transaction at all, which means a sale of ETF shares wouldn't result in the ETF itself having to sell securities at all. No sale of securities, no capital gain to pass along to existing ETF investors.

Sometimes, however, there may not be enough existing shareholders willing to sell shares to wannabe ETF investors -- or enough wannabe ETF investors to buy shares from ETF shareholders who want to sell. At such times, there's a unique process for creating and redeeming shares without triggering tax consequences.

To create new shares, a brokerage firm or institutional investor buys a basket of securities that exactly mirrors the holdings of the ETF. That firm then gives the securities to the ETF in return for new shares of the ETF.

To redeem shares, the process works in reverse. The brokerage firm presents ETF shares to the ETF in return for a basket of securities from the ETF equal to the value of the ETF shares. The firm then sells those securities in the market for cash that goes to redeeming investors.

Since the ETF itself only exchanges shares for securities in the case of a redemption -- as opposed to actually selling the securities as a mutual fund does -- the transaction doesn't generate a taxable distributions for shareholders. This process gives ETFs an advantage when it comes to tax efficiency.

ETFs can sometimes generate taxable gains

Keep in mind, though, that ETFs can still sometimes generate taxable gains. If the index they track drops some stocks and adds others, then they must sell shares of the stocks that have been jettisoned from the index, which can result in capital gains distributions to shareholders, although there are also techniques for minimizing gains in such situations.

This process also helps ETFs stay in synch with their indexes, although they can still stray. To get an idea of how tightly an ETF tracks its index, you can go to Morningstar.com, plug the ETF's ticker symbol into the Quotes/Reports box and then check out the Key Stats section of the Snapshot page. The Total Return section also compares returns based on the ETF's net asset value and the ETF's market trading price.

The extent to which this unique method for creating and redeeming shares translates to an after-tax performance edge, however, depending on such factors as the expenses of a particular ETF vs. a similar index mutual fund, how often stocks move in and out of the index, the brokerage commissions and other transaction costs involved in buying ETFs, the size of the investment you make and how long you hold that investment.

I can tell you that this ETF-vs. Index Funds debate can get very complicated and esoteric. If you're into that sort of thing, though, you can click here, here and here to really get into it.

Good for the long term large investor

Generally, though, I'd say that if you are investing large sums of money (say, $10,000 or more) and keeping that money invested for the long-term (at least 5 years, preferably more), ETFs based on the more popular benchmarks such as the Standard & Poor's 500, the Nasdaq 100 and indexes that track the entire U.S. stock market (such as the Dow Jones Total Market Index) stand a good chance of delivering better performance, although I don't think the difference is enough for people who invest in index mutual funds to stay up nights worrying about.

If you tend to dollar-cost-average or invest smaller amounts periodically, then index mutual funds are probably a better bet. Otherwise, you may incur brokerage costs that can erode or wipe out any advantage ETFs might otherwise have.

Finally, let's not forget to keep this in perspective. If you're investing for the long-term using low-cost options like ETFs and index mutual funds, you're likely to do better than those investors who chase whatever funds happen to be on this year's top-performer lists and who buy high-cost funds in the mistaken belief that highly paid managers and fund companies will outperform.

So while fund fanatics might get all hyped up about whether ETFs or index mutual funds are the best choice, my feeling is that you can do quite well in either one and much better than in most of the other choices out there.

Visit the CNN/Money ETF Center by clicking here.

Walter Updegrave is a senior editor at MONEY Magazine and is the author of "We're Not in Kansas Anymore: Strategies for Retiring Rich in a Totally Changed World." To top of page

Frontline troops push for solar energy
The U.S. Marines are testing renewable energy technologies like solar to reduce costs and casualties associated with fossil fuels. Play
25 Best Places to find rich singles
Looking for Mr. or Ms. Moneybags? Hunt down the perfect mate in these wealthy cities, which are brimming with unattached professionals. More
Fun festivals: Twins to mustard to pirates!
You'll see double in Twinsburg, Ohio, and Ketchup lovers should beware in Middleton, WI. Here's some of the best and strangest town festivals. Play
Overnight Avg Rate Latest Change Last Week
30 yr fixed4.01%4.03%
15 yr fixed3.12%2.97%
5/1 ARM3.11%2.99%
30 yr refi4.04%4.09%
15 yr refi3.15%3.05%
Rate data provided
by Bankrate.com
View rates in your area
 
Find personalized rates:
Index Last Change % Change
Dow 17,804.80 26.65 0.15%
Nasdaq 4,765.38 16.98 0.36%
S&P 500 2,070.65 9.42 0.46%
Treasuries 2.18 -0.03 -1.27%
Data as of 9:43pm ET
Company Price Change % Change
Bank of America Corp... 17.62 0.09 0.51%
Apple Inc 111.78 -0.87 -0.77%
General Electric Co 25.62 0.48 1.91%
Intel Corp 36.37 -0.65 -1.76%
Microsoft Corp 47.66 0.14 0.29%
Data as of 4:04pm ET

Sections

New York Magazine reporter Jessica Pressler, who has been caught up in controversy this past week, will not be moving on to a new job at Bloomberg News. More

Investors beware: These 5 global crises are likely to rattle the stock market and world economy. More

Forums in dark corners of the web sell the kinds of hacks that befell Sony. More

Unilever sued Hampton Creek over its egg-free mayonnaise spread Just Mayo. But the company behind Best Foods and Hellman's mayonnaise has now dropped the lawsuit. More

The income of the top 1% jumped significantly in 2012, far outpacing inflation. Not only did this group make a larger share of the country's income, their share of total taxes also jumped from 35% to 38%. More

Most stock quote data provided by BATS. Market indices are shown in real time, except for the DJIA, which is delayed by two minutes. All times are ET. Disclaimer.

Morningstar: © 2014 Morningstar, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Factset: FactSet Research Systems Inc. 2014. All rights reserved.

Chicago Mercantile Association: Certain market data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved.

Dow Jones: The Dow Jones branded indices are proprietary to and are calculated, distributed and marketed by DJI Opco, a subsidiary of S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC and have been licensed for use to S&P Opco, LLC and CNN. Standard & Poor's and S&P are registered trademarks of Standard & Poor’s Financial Services LLC and Dow Jones is a registered trademark of Dow Jones Trademark Holdings LLC. All content of the Dow Jones branded indices © S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC 2014 and/or its affiliates.