Our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy have changed.

By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to the new Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

Toyota: Sudden acceleration test unrealistic

by Peter Valdes-Dapena, senior writer

NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) -- Toyota is rejecting a university professor's test that claims to show that electronic throttle systems on Toyota cars could cause unintended acceleration saying the test was simply not realistic.

Dr. David Gilbert of Southern Illinois University performed a demonstration of how the problem could occur in an ABC News broadcast in late February. Later, Gilbert testified before a Congressional hearing looking into unintended acceleration in Toyota cars.

10 best cars: Consumer Reports
The influential magazine names the cars, trucks and SUVs it rates highest in popular categories.

"Dr. Gilbert's demonstration, as shown on the ABC News web site, amounts to little more than connecting three of the six pedal sensor wires to an engineered circuit to achieve engine revving," said Exponent, a research firm hired by Toyota, in a report obtained by CNN that was prepared for Toyota attorneys.

Some safety consultants have alleged that electronic throttle control, or ETC, systems used on Toyota cars are a likely cause of unintended acceleration problems. Toyota has said it is studying the issue but has not found any fault in the electronic systems that would lead to unintended acceleration in real world conditions.

Still, Toyota (TM) has recalled more than 8 million cars for mechanical problems including issues related to the gas pedals.

Gilbert said he had uncovered a potential for a short circuit that could undermine the electronic throttle control system's built in safety checks.

The system used on Toyota cars relies on two separate sensors connected to the gas pedal and another pair connected to the throttle valve itself. In order for the system to work, each sensor in a pair has to match. If they don't match in the proper way, an on-board computer immediately senses a problem and the engine power is reduced to idle or it's shut off altogether.

Gilbert said that he overrode that safety feature, allowing faulty pedal signals to go to the engine with no problem being detected by the car's on-board computer.

Exponent, the research firm hired by Toyota, was able to replicate Gilbert's results but says that the test presents an unrealistic situation that has virtually no chance of happening in the real world.

"For such an event to happen in the real world requires a sequence of faults that is extraordinarily unlikely," the report continues.

Exponent was also able to replicate the same sequence of short circuits, with the same result, in other automakers' cars, which would undercut the allegation that the problem would be somehow unique to Toyotas.

"Every vehicle from other manufacturers tested by Exponent could be induced to respond with a sudden increase in engine speed and power output," Exponent said in a fact sheet. "These demonstrations in no way indicate a defect with any of the vehicles tested (including the Toyota Avalon and Camry)."

A representative for Southern Illinois University said that Dr. Gilbert has already met with Toyota representatives and that more meetings are planned. To top of page

Find Your Next Car
Index Last Change % Change
Dow 17,060.77 -71.09 -0.41%
Nasdaq 4,817.85 -20.79 -0.43%
S&P 500 2,009.30 -8.16 -0.40%
Treasuries 2.06 -0.03 -1.34%
Data as of 9:39am ET
Company Price Change % Change
Micron Technology In... 18.03 -0.13 -0.72%
Microsoft Corp 47.00 -0.11 -0.23%
Cisco Systems Inc 27.96 0.04 0.14%
Marathon Oil Corp 18.96 -0.62 -3.16%
Frontier Communicati... 5.11 -0.08 -1.54%
Data as of Oct 12


Anheuser-Busch InBev has agreed to purchase its main rival SABMiller, creating a super brewery with sales of $55 billion. More

Over three million Europeans have signed a petition against a planned free trade agreement with the U.S. What's the problem? More

Twitter has laid off 336 employees as part of new CEO Jack Dorsey's first round of job cuts. More