Innovation in Education

How 'Waiting for 'Superman" misses

By David A. Kaplan, contributor

FORTUNE -- It would be churlish not to recognize that the new documentary "Waiting for 'Superman'" is a well-intentioned cry for reform in American public education. Director Davis Guggenheim, who won a 2007 Oscar for "An Inconvenient Truth," even performs political magic: "Superman" is a lefty's screed that right-wingers have lauded. Almost every reviewer loved it. I did, too, but on reflection I've got a beef.

The problem is the movie's conclusion that the charter schools it champions are a panacea. The movie is wise enough to recognize that parents, teachers, unions, politicians, philanthropists, and social scientists all have axes to grind on charter schools. And yet the film fails to question its own assumptions. It ought to.

"Superman" follows five young students from poor neighborhoods across the country. All five want to attend charter schools, but there aren't enough spaces. The law requires a heartbreaking lottery to fill the slots; there are no tests or interviews. Whether the students get in (and thus out of their traditional public schools), we're told, will largely determine their futures. Their odds aren't good. Bianca wants to attend Harlem Success Academy in New York City; there are 35 spaces for 767 applicants. Daisy has applied to KIPP in Los Angeles (10 spaces, 135 applicants). And so forth. Fair enough, yet the movie fails to ask: If these charters are that good -- and they're free -- shouldn't every child in the eligible area be applying? Why isn't the number of applicants far higher?

One reasonable answer is that the applicants represent a self-selected sample. By definition, they and their parents were highly motivated to find alternatives to the default neighborhood schools to which their zip code sentenced them. So this group may already be headed for better test scores and other gauges of achievement -- in the same way that students in Scarsdale, N.Y., and Palo Alto succeed less because of what happens inside their schools and more because of who they are and how they were raised.

Some academics have tried to account for the self-selection flaw. Last year Stanford economist Caroline Hoxby published a controversial study examining the academic performance of students who "lost" charter school lotteries in New York and wound up attending traditional public schools. Hoxby found that those students did less well than their charter-school peers over a seven-year period. But other scholars have challenged her methodology. There's also the reality that many charter schools with lotteries don't produce great results like those exalted in "Superman." Therefore, motivated families alone don't dictate educational outcomes. The quality of a charter and its teachers surely matters.

The ideal way to measure a charter school's utility would be to pick students randomly from a pool of all eligible candidates, thus removing the distorting influence of self-selection. That's unlikely. But in the absence of truly random selection, the movie's certainty that schools make all the difference seems misplaced. So, too, may be the dollars of businesses and foundations clamoring to fund elite charters. To top of page

Frontline troops push for solar energy
The U.S. Marines are testing renewable energy technologies like solar to reduce costs and casualties associated with fossil fuels. Play
25 Best Places to find rich singles
Looking for Mr. or Ms. Moneybags? Hunt down the perfect mate in these wealthy cities, which are brimming with unattached professionals. More
Fun festivals: Twins to mustard to pirates!
You'll see double in Twinsburg, Ohio, and Ketchup lovers should beware in Middleton, WI. Here's some of the best and strangest town festivals. Play
Company Price Change % Change
Bank of America Corp... 15.52 0.07 0.45%
Apple Inc 100.57 0.04 0.04%
General Electric Co 26.36 0.31 1.19%
Intel Corp 34.50 0.16 0.47%
Staples Inc 11.32 -0.30 -2.62%
Data as of Aug 20
Index Last Change % Change
Dow 16,979.13 59.54 0.35%
Nasdaq 4,526.48 -1.03 -0.02%
S&P 500 1,986.51 4.91 0.25%
Treasuries 2.43 0.02 0.87%
Data as of 6:47am ET


Russian officials have shut four McDonald's restaurants in Moscow, including the first to open in the city nearly 25 years ago at the end of the Cold War. More

Median income is up 3.8% since 2011, though it's still down since the economic recovery began in 2009. More

Small business owners say the economy is still their biggest challenge, which keeps them from expanding and hiring, according to a CNNMoney-Manta survey. More

This month, Delaware became the first state to pass a law giving heirs the right to access the online accounts and assets of someone who has passed away. More

Market indexes are shown in real time, except for the DJIA, which is delayed by two minutes. All times are ET. Disclaimer Morningstar: © 2014 Morningstar, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer The Dow Jones IndexesSM are proprietary to and distributed by Dow Jones & Company, Inc. and have been licensed for use. All content of the Dow Jones IndexesSM © 2014 is proprietary to Dow Jones & Company, Inc. Chicago Mercantile Association. The market data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved. FactSet Research Systems Inc. 2014. All rights reserved. Most stock quote data provided by BATS.