FCC is playing hardball with AT&T

AT&T's merger with T-Mobile might not go down as smoothly as it had expected, after a recent FCC ruling shows the regulator is getting tough with big wireless providers. By David Goldman, staff writer

NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- A harsh ruling against the nation's largest wireless companies last week suggests U.S. regulators aren't going to lie down and let AT&T scoop up T-Mobile without a fight.

On Thursday, the Federal Communications Commission announced that it will force mobile networks to negotiate data roaming agreements with smaller providers. The order was aimed at the biggest carriers, AT&T and Verizon, which have amassed the largest data networks but frequently refused to make deals with smaller competitors.

Every wireless company that filed a comment on the order was in support of it -- except Verizon (VZ, Fortune 500) and AT&T (T, Fortune 500), a fact that FCC Commissioner Julius Genachowski said he couldn't ignore. The FCC's order essentially called the wireless space a duopoly.

Experts say the ruling serves as a harbinger of things to come. The FCC -- along with the Justice Department, one of the two regulators that must approve the AT&T / T-Mobile deal -- will likely demand strict concessions in order to let the proposed merger go through.

"In requiring that large network operators open their networks to roaming, the FCC is showing its hand in how it will deal with ongoing consolidation in the wireless industry," said Dan Hays, a telecom consultant at PRTM. "This latest ruling from the FCC indicates that they are seeking to limit the power and control exerted by the nation's largest network operators."

Typically, in approving wireless mergers, U.S. regulators require very large companies to divest a portion of their stakes in markets in which they are dominant, usually in the form of selling off wireless spectrum. But given AT&T's size and the FCC's recent action, many analysts expect the Commission to go above and beyond the norm when dealing with the proposed merger with T-Mobile.

In addition to divestitures in small markets, most analysts said they expect the FCC to force AT&T to agree to Net neutrality provisions, open standards for network access, and roaming service agreements with smaller players.

Others think the regulator may limit the number or duration of exclusivity agreements that AT&T signs with manufacturers of the hottest new devices. The company's four-year exclusive carrier agreement with Apple (AAPL, Fortune 500) for the iPhone was one of the longest in the industry's history.

Pricing may play a role as well: T-Mobile is one of the largest low-cost carriers with a national footprint. The FCC could impose rate-hike limitations on AT&T and force it to honor T-Mobile customers' agreements for a number of years.

A few experts also said the FCC would likely impose restrictions on AT&T in the amount of wireless spectrum it could buy in the future. More spectrum is needed to prevent bottlenecking, and the Commission is expected to open up for auction 500 MHz of spectrum later this decade. One of AT&T's chief stated reasons for purchasing T-Mobile is to acquire more access to spectrum.

Forecast: Merger will get approved

If the merger is approved, AT&T would be the largest wireless provider in the nation by 30%, and both AT&T and Verizon would control more than 70% of the market.

Still, every analyst and expert we spoke to believed the FCC and the DOJ would allow the deal to go through.

The FCC has typically been very open to wireless mergers and has not, until very recently, disputed industry claims of fervent competition. Despite the regulator's "unusual candor" in its ruling last week, Rob Frieden, professor of telecommunications and law at Penn State University, said that the FCC wouldn't dare turn the merger down.

"In this environment, the merger probably goes down subject to rigorous concessions, most of which AT&T will 'volunteer' in the next few months," said Frieden, via e-mail. "On the other hand I don't see the FCC saying no to AT&T."

In fact, many analysts agreed that the FCC's recent "get tough" policy hints that it will try to use concessions rather than roadblocks as a tool to regulate the industry in the future.

"I think this implies that the FCC or the Justice Department will be more likely to approve the merger, since their concerns about harm to rival firms will have been addressed in part through regulation," said Keith Hylton, a professor at Boston University's school of law. To top of page

Frontline troops push for solar energy
The U.S. Marines are testing renewable energy technologies like solar to reduce costs and casualties associated with fossil fuels. Play
25 Best Places to find rich singles
Looking for Mr. or Ms. Moneybags? Hunt down the perfect mate in these wealthy cities, which are brimming with unattached professionals. More
Fun festivals: Twins to mustard to pirates!
You'll see double in Twinsburg, Ohio, and Ketchup lovers should beware in Middleton, WI. Here's some of the best and strangest town festivals. Play

Search for Jobs

Index Last Change % Change
Dow 17,776.12 -200.19 -1.11%
Nasdaq 4,900.89 -46.56 -0.94%
S&P 500 2,067.89 -18.35 -0.88%
Treasuries 1.93 -0.03 -1.48%
Data as of 2:15am ET
Company Price Change % Change
Bank of America Corp... 15.39 -0.13 -0.84%
Apple Inc 124.43 -1.94 -1.54%
General Electric Co 24.81 -0.31 -1.23%
Microsoft Corp 40.66 -0.30 -0.74%
Intel Corp 31.27 -0.19 -0.60%
Data as of Mar 31


Walmart CEO Doug McMillon asked the govenor of Arkansas to veto a religious freedom law similar to the one adopted by Indiana last week. More

U.S. Treasury Secretary Jack Lew said Tuesday that China's yuan is not yet ready to join an elite grouping of currencies used by the International Monetary Fund. More

Amazon's new Dash button lets users program products to buy with the click of a literal button. More

Low-income families plan to spend more than 5% of their income on prom this year, according to a new survey from Visa. More