Housing outlook for 2010

This year the housing market showed signs of life. But with foreclosures and unemployment climbing, prices have further to fall.

EMAIL  |   PRINT  |   SHARE  |   RSS
 
google my aol my msn my yahoo! netvibes
Paste this link into your favorite RSS desktop reader
See all CNNMoney.com RSS FEEDS (close)
By Beth Kowitt, reporter

housing_map.03.gif
Moody's Economy.com compiles an annual forecast for home prices based on national and local indicators in 100 U.S. metropolitan areas. Only one market -- Pittsburgh -- is expected to turn positive in 2010. See table below for details.
Which type of investments will you focus on in 2010?
  • U.S. stocks
  • Emerging markets
  • Bonds
  • Commodities
  • Im sticking with old-fashioned bank accounts
Mortgage Rates
30 yr fixed 3.80%
15 yr fixed 3.20%
5/1 ARM 3.84%
30 yr refi 3.82%
15 yr refi 3.20%

Find personalized rates:
 

Rates provided by Bankrate.com.

(Fortune magazine) -- In a dour year for the economy, the housing market has offered some glimmers of hope. Home sales have improved, recently hitting their highest level in more than two years. There's been talk of bidding wars resuming in places like Silicon Valley and New York City. And cocktail party chatter everywhere has started to turn to talk of a bottom. So at least where housing's concerned, things are looking not so bad -- right?

If that's what you think, you may not want to invite Mark Zandi to your next cocktail party. The chief economist of Moody's Economy.com, Zandi has some sobering predictions: Home prices are going to fall 5% to 10% more -- and over 30% in places like Miami -- between now and this time next year. Then they might start turning around. (Emphasis on "might.")

At the top of Zandi's list of worries are foreclosures -- specifically, the millions of loans that are in foreclosure or headed there that can't or won't be modified. According to RealtyTrac, nearly 2 million housing units in the U.S. are in foreclosure or bank-owned, and millions more are likely to join them.

Zandi estimates that 2.4 million homes will find their way into foreclosure next year. He expects banks to start putting those properties on the market more aggressively during the first half of the year, resulting in a flood of cut-rate inventory that will drag prices down.

It would be one thing if banks could sell into a hungry real estate market. But that brings us to Zandi's second concern: skyhigh unemployment.

October's 10.2% figure was higher than what most economists forecast for the peak. A soft job market, especially one this soft, means potential buyers don't have money to pour into new homes or the confidence that they'll be able to hang on to their jobs and pay the mortgage on their existing home.

Another concern: Policymakers will pull their support from the market prematurely. Aggressive government moves, like the recently extended first-time-homebuyer tax credit and the Fed's purchase of mortgage-backed securities, have been propping up the market.

The purchase plan is set to expire in March, which Zandi says could bump mortgage rates up as much as a full point. "That raises the cost of buying a home, and in this fragile market people won't buy," he says. "And that's a problem."

All those factors are figured into Economy.com's housing price outlook for 2010 -- as are local figures for income, population, interest rates, and foreclosures.

The results are broken into 100 metropolitan areas. (Last year the projections were pretty accurate, forecasting a 14.5% decline in 2009; the actual figure is likely to come in around --13.2%.)

As the sea of red above shows, the numbers are negative across the country.

The weakest areas are Florida, California, Nevada, and Arizona -- what Zandi calls the "usual suspects" -- where foreclosures are highest and likely to rise. The worst market: Miami, where the 2009 median home price of $183,530 is expected to fall 33%.

But Zandi also points to less discussed regions where prices are still inflated relative to rents, like the Pacific Northwest and New York through Virginia.

If there's a bright spot, it's pockets of the Midwest -- states like the Dakotas, Kansas, and Nebraska, which have stronger economies based on agricultural and energy industries.

Then there's Pittsburgh, which didn't have much of a housing bubble to begin with and is the only market projected to grow next year, up 0.41%.

The good news? "It's clear we're closer to the end of this crash than the beginning," says Zandi. Housing is more affordable, and construction is still low, so sales will eat up excess inventory. "We're moving in the right direction, and that's reason for optimism," he says.

Another plus: He says there's almost zero possibility of another U.S. housing bubble anytime soon. To top of page

Rank by 2010 price change Metro Area 2009 median house price Projected price change 2010 Projected price change 2011
1 Pittsburgh, PA 114,750 0.41% 2.23%
2 Rochester, NY 114,630 -0.39% 1.93%
3 Birmingham, AL 139,330 -0.78% 1.29%
4 Memphis, TN 107,690 -1.53% 2.41%
5 Buffalo, NY 108,170 -1.54% 0.86%
6 Houston, TX 146,350 -1.75% 0.38%
7 Kansas City, MO 135,420 -1.81% 0.16%
8 Louisville, KY 124,660 -2.24% 1.05%
9 Little Rock, AR 130,380 -2.27% 2.01%
10 Charlotte, NC 185,880 -2.30% 1.42%
11 Wichita, KS 115,260 -2.32% 0.42%
12 St. Louis, MO 115,720 -2.39% 0.28%
13 Dallas, TX 149,320 -2.57% 0.39%
14 Fort Worth, TX 118,920 -2.59% 0.44%
15 Columbia, SC 135,980 -2.66% 1.96%
16 Omaha, NE 131,290 -2.75% 1.46%
17 Denver, CO 204,570 -2.79% 3.02%
18 Greensboro, NC 135,920 -2.80% 0.95%
19 Albany, NY 188,600 -2.82% 0.78%
20 Baton Rouge, LA 160,370 -2.85% 0.39%
21 Tulsa, OK 131,600 -2.86% 1.50%
22 Syracuse, NY 122,420 -2.87% 2.32%
23 New Orleans, LA 158,900 -3.10% -0.69%
24 Indianapolis, IN 105,100 -3.23% 0.73%
25 Gary, IN 101,180 -3.30% 0.44%
26 Austin, TX 187,590 -3.33% 0.96%
27 Seattle, WA 340,050 -3.42% 6.54%
28 San Antonio, TX 148,580 -3.71% 0.71%
29 Grand Rapids, MI 76,620 -3.88% 0.83%
30 Milwaukee, WI 199,820 -3.92% -0.22%
31 Oklahoma City, OK 127,740 -4.02% 0.98%
32 Greenville, SC 140,430 -4.10% 1.26%
33 El Paso, TX 131,350 -4.27% 1.03%
34 Chicago, IL 200,650 -4.30% 2.24%
35 Raleigh, NC 215,510 -4.38% 1.91%
36 McAllen, TX 62,280 -4.54% 2.29%
37 Boston, MA 315,020 -4.56% 3.42%
38 Cambridge, MA 341,430 -4.73% 4.17%
39 Oakland, CA 360,660 -4.97% 11.96%
40 Minneapolis, MN 178,870 -4.99% 2.31%
41 Atlanta, GA 117,910 -5.12% 1.71%
42 Lake County, IL 223,770 -5.39% 1.10%
43 Richmond, VA 203,100 -5.50% 1.29%
44 Tacoma, WA 210,430 -5.57% 10.82%
45 Knoxville, TN 141,240 -5.76% 0.90%
46 Toledo, OH 74,940 -6.00% 2.40%
47 Washington, DC 288,280 -6.26% 4.61%
48 Nashville, TN 166,150 -6.36% 0.64%
49 Warren, MI 142,450 -6.40% 2.59%
50 Columbus, OH 129,030 -6.54% 2.02%
51 Cleveland, OH 86,910 -6.98% 1.34%
52 Allentown, PA 219,080 -7.17% -0.78%
53 Worcester, MA 199,410 -7.39% 1.70%
54 Dayton, OH 91,420 -7.43% 1.17%
55 Bridgeport, CT 377,710 -7.62% 2.30%
56 San Francisco, CA 510,210 -7.97% 14.30%
57 Cincinnati, OH 113,320 -8.30% 1.19%
58 Akron, OH 68,030 -8.42% 1.17%
59 Virginia Beach, VA 202,660 -8.58% -2.37%
60 Portland, OR 241,650 -9.01% 5.35%
61 Hartford, CT 228,810 -9.02% 4.89%
62 Springfield, MA 181,150 -9.18% 4.48%
63 Peabody, MA 292,300 -9.23% 4.80%
64 Philadelphia, PA 209,070 -9.23% 5.20%
65 Detroit, MI 83,360 -9.40% 2.82%
66 New Haven, CT 226,560 -10.50% 3.97%
67 Youngstown, OH 60,330 -10.71% 1.61%
68 Bethesda, MD 332,910 -11.02% 1.05%
69 Albuquerque, NM 177,680 -11.03% 2.89%
70 Poughkeepsie, NY 220,170 -11.24% 0.72%
71 Newark, NJ 367,380 -11.29% 4.53%
72 San Diego, CA 325,600 -11.65% 9.62%
73 Providence, RI 208,170 -12.09% 3.51%
74 Honolulu, HI 551,910 -12.81% 3.31%
75 Sacramento, CA 169,100 -12.87% 6.10%
76 Nassau, NY 368,260 -13.14% -3.65%
77 Santa Ana, CA 436,680 -13.15% 6.32%
78 Edison, NJ 323,260 -13.25% 2.77%
79 Wilmington, DE 199,940 -13.28% 2.34%
80 Salt Lake City, UT 215,530 -13.31% 2.31%
81 Baltimore, MD 243,980 -13.87% 2.65%
82 Camden, NJ 197,470 -14.12% 1.36%
83 San Jose, CA 461,660 -15.28% 6.14%
84 New York, NY 416,730 -15.63% -1.33%
85 Tucson, AZ 170,650 -15.93% 2.97%
86 Stockton, CA 166,300 -15.98% 10.08%
87 Bakersfield, CA 159,070 -16.31% 9.82%
88 Oxnard, CA 283,240 -17.52% 8.58%
89 Fresno, CA 184,720 -17.71% 7.19%
90 Riverside, CA 162,240 -18.90% 7.71%
91 Los Angeles, CA 260,250 -19.41% 8.43%
92 Phoenix, AZ 122,770 -20.50% 0.74%
93 Jacksonville, FL 145,250 -22.31% 0.09%
94 Tampa, FL 135,260 -22.77% 1.26%
95 Las Vegas, NV 137,410 -23.65% -0.93%
96 West Palm Beach, FL 223,470 -23.85% 1.39%
97 Bradenton, FL 152,640 -25.98% 0.60%
98 Fort Lauderdale, FL 187,170 -30.16% -1.59%
99 Orlando, FL 142,920 -30.73% -2.40%
100 Miami, FL 183,530 -32.99% -4.20%
Rank by 2010 price change Metro Area 2009 median house price Projected price change 2010 Projected price change 2011
1 Kansas City, MO 135,420 -1.81% 0.16%
2 Wichita, KS 115,260 -2.32% 0.42%
3 St. Louis, MO 115,720 -2.39% 0.28%
4 Omaha, NE 131,290 -2.75% 1.46%
5 Indianapolis, IN 105,100 -3.23% 0.73%
6 Gary, IN 101,180 -3.30% 0.44%
7 Grand Rapids, MI 76,620 -3.88% 0.83%
8 Milwaukee, WI 199,820 -3.92% -0.22%
9 Chicago, IL 200,650 -4.30% 2.24%
10 Minneapolis, MN 178,870 -4.99% 2.31%
11 Lake County, IL 223,770 -5.39% 1.10%
12 Toledo, OH 74,940 -6.00% 2.40%
13 Warren, MI 142,450 -6.40% 2.59%
14 Columbus, OH 129,030 -6.54% 2.02%
15 Cleveland, OH 86,910 -6.98% 1.34%
16 Dayton, OH 91,420 -7.43% 1.17%
17 Cincinnati, OH 113,320 -8.30% 1.19%
18 Akron, OH 68,030 -8.42% 1.17%
19 Detroit, MI 83,360 -9.40% 2.82%
20 Youngstown, OH 60,330 -10.71% 1.61%
Rank by 2010 price change Metro Area 2009 median house price Projected price change 2010 Projected price change 2011
1 Pittsburgh, PA 114,750 0.41% 2.23%
2 Rochester, NY 114,630 -0.39% 1.93%
3 Buffalo, NY 108,170 -1.54% 0.86%
4 Albany, NY 188,600 -2.82% 0.78%
5 Syracuse, NY 122,420 -2.87% 2.32%
6 Boston, MA 315,020 -4.56% 3.42%
7 Cambridge, MA 341,430 -4.73% 4.17%
8 Allentown, PA 219,080 -7.17% -0.78%
9 Worcester, MA 199,410 -7.39% 1.70%
10 Bridgeport, CT 377,710 -7.62% 2.30%
11 Hartford, CT 228,810 -9.02% 4.89%
12 Springfield, MA 181,150 -9.18% 4.48%
13 Peabody, MA 292,300 -9.23% 4.80%
14 Philadelphia, PA 209,070 -9.23% 5.20%
15 New Haven, CT 226,560 -10.50% 3.97%
16 Poughkeepsie, NY 220,170 -11.24% 0.72%
17 Newark, NJ 367,380 -11.29% 4.53%
18 Providence, RI 208,170 -12.09% 3.51%
19 Nassau, NY 368,260 -13.14% -3.65%
20 Edison, NJ 323,260 -13.25% 2.77%
21 Camden, NJ 197,470 -14.12% 1.36%
22 New York, NY 416,730 -15.63% -1.33%
Rank by 2010 price change Metro Area 2009 median house price Projected price change 2010 Projected price change 2011
1 Birmingham, AL 139,330 -0.78% 1.29%
2 Memphis, TN 107,690 -1.53% 2.41%
3 Houston, TX 146,350 -1.75% 0.38%
4 Louisville, KY 124,660 -2.24% 1.05%
5 Little Rock, AR 130,380 -2.27% 2.01%
6 Charlotte, NC 185,880 -2.30% 1.42%
7 Dallas, TX 149,320 -2.57% 0.39%
8 Fort Worth, TX 118,920 -2.59% 0.44%
9 Columbia, SC 135,980 -2.66% 1.96%
10 Greensboro, NC 135,920 -2.80% 0.95%
11 Baton Rouge, LA 160,370 -2.85% 0.39%
12 Tulsa, OK 131,600 -2.86% 1.50%
13 New Orleans, LA 158,900 -3.10% -0.69%
14 Austin, TX 187,590 -3.33% 0.96%
15 San Antonio, TX 148,580 -3.71% 0.71%
16 Oklahoma City, OK 127,740 -4.02% 0.98%
17 Greenville, SC 140,430 -4.10% 1.26%
18 El Paso, TX 131,350 -4.27% 1.03%
19 Raleigh, NC 215,510 -4.38% 1.91%
20 McAllen, TX 62,280 -4.54% 2.29%
21 Atlanta, GA 117,910 -5.12% 1.71%
22 Richmond, VA 203,100 -5.50% 1.29%
23 Knoxville, TN 141,240 -5.76% 0.90%
24 Washington, DC 288,280 -6.26% 4.61%
25 Nashville, TN 166,150 -6.36% 0.64%
26 Virginia Beach, VA 202,660 -8.58% -2.37%
27 Bethesda, MD 332,910 -11.02% 1.05%
28 Wilmington, DE 199,940 -13.28% 2.34%
29 Baltimore, MD 243,980 -13.87% 2.65%
30 Jacksonville, FL 145,250 -22.31% 0.09%
31 Tampa, FL 135,260 -22.77% 1.26%
32 West Palm Beach, FL 223,470 -23.85% 1.39%
33 Bradenton, FL 152,640 -25.98% 0.60%
34 Fort Lauderdale, FL 187,170 -30.16% -1.59%
35 Orlando, FL 142,920 -30.73% -2.40%
36 Miami, FL 183,530 -32.99% -4.20%
Rank by 2010 price change Metro Area 2009 median house price Projected price change 2010 Projected price change 2011
1 Denver, CO 204,570 -2.79% 3.02%
2 Seattle, WA 340,050 -3.42% 6.54%
3 Oakland, CA 360,660 -4.97% 11.96%
4 Tacoma, WA 210,430 -5.57% 10.82%
5 San Francisco, CA 510,210 -7.97% 14.30%
6 Portland, OR 241,650 -9.01% 5.35%
7 Albuquerque, NM 177,680 -11.03% 2.89%
8 San Diego, CA 325,600 -11.65% 9.62%
9 Honolulu, HI 551,910 -12.81% 3.31%
10 Sacramento, CA 169,100 -12.87% 6.10%
11 Santa Ana, CA 436,680 -13.15% 6.32%
12 Salt Lake City, UT 215,530 -13.31% 2.31%
13 San Jose, CA 461,660 -15.28% 6.14%
14 Tucson, AZ 170,650 -15.93% 2.97%
15 Stockton, CA 166,300 -15.98% 10.08%
16 Bakersfield, CA 159,070 -16.31% 9.82%
17 Oxnard, CA 283,240 -17.52% 8.58%
18 Fresno, CA 184,720 -17.71% 7.19%
19 Riverside, CA 162,240 -18.90% 7.71%
20 Los Angeles, CA 260,250 -19.41% 8.43%
21 Phoenix, AZ 122,770 -20.50% 0.74%
22 Las Vegas, NV 137,410 -23.65% -0.93%
Find mortgage rates in your area


Company Price Change % Change
Bank of America Corp... 29.88 0.75 2.56%
Advanced Micro Devic... 30.70 0.17 0.56%
Wells Fargo & Co 51.21 1.94 3.94%
General Electric Co 8.87 0.15 1.72%
Ford Motor Co 9.09 0.27 3.06%
Data as of 12:14pm ET
Index Last Change % Change
Dow 27,027.17 239.81 0.90%
Nasdaq 8,141.66 93.02 1.16%
S&P 500 2,997.37 31.22 1.05%
Treasuries 1.75 0.02 1.21%
Data as of 12:29pm ET
More Galleries
10 of the most luxurious airline amenity kits When it comes to in-flight pampering, the amenity kits offered by these 10 airlines are the ultimate in luxury More
7 startups that want to improve your mental health From a text therapy platform to apps that push you reminders to breathe, these self-care startups offer help on a daily basis or in times of need. More
5 radical technologies that will change how you get to work From Uber's flying cars to the Hyperloop, these are some of the neatest transportation concepts in the works today. More
Sponsors
Worry about the hackers you don't know 
Crime syndicates and government organizations pose a much greater cyber threat than renegade hacker groups like Anonymous. Play
GE CEO: Bringing jobs back to the U.S. 
Jeff Immelt says the U.S. is a cost competitive market for advanced manufacturing and that GE is bringing jobs back from Mexico. Play
Hamster wheel and wedgie-powered transit 
Red Bull Creation challenges hackers and engineers to invent new modes of transportation. Play

Most stock quote data provided by BATS. Market indices are shown in real time, except for the DJIA, which is delayed by two minutes. All times are ET. Disclaimer. Morningstar: © 2018 Morningstar, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Factset: FactSet Research Systems Inc. 2018. All rights reserved. Chicago Mercantile Association: Certain market data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved. Dow Jones: The Dow Jones branded indices are proprietary to and are calculated, distributed and marketed by DJI Opco, a subsidiary of S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC and have been licensed for use to S&P Opco, LLC and CNN. Standard & Poor's and S&P are registered trademarks of Standard & Poor's Financial Services LLC and Dow Jones is a registered trademark of Dow Jones Trademark Holdings LLC. All content of the Dow Jones branded indices © S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC 2018 and/or its affiliates.