Our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy have changed.

By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to the new Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

Money and Main Street
9 of 12
BACKNEXT
Why wasn't TARP enough?
Question: "Shouldn't TARP have been enough for the banks to at least recoup a majority of their losses and stabilize their balance sheets?" -- Matt Sedlak, Littlestown, Penn.

Expert: Michele Boldrin, professor of economics, University of Washington in St. Louis

Answer: "There are two answers, the quick, nasty one and the longer more detailed one.

The quick, nasty one is that the losses were bigger than the money we put in. The longer answer is that not all of the money was used to cover the losses; some of it was used to pay for bonuses and things like that.

But the truth is that if we put in $500 billion, we'd still be about a trillion short. The TARP approach is to basically avoid any kind of major bank failure. But some losses are real and we just have to accept that we had invested money into things for years that we assumed were worth X. But it turns out they were worth quite a bit less - and that 'quite a bit' is gone.

For example, when bad investments are made, you have to make future readjustments. Like with mortgage lending. There was a substantial amount lent out to build homes and remodel them: $11.7 trillion, to be exact. The banks put that on the balance sheet as profit for when it is paid back. But now people are not able to pay it back, so what looked like profit isn't. So in order to balance out that loss, you would have to put money in to cover it, but there isn't enough money being put in to cover the losses.

The current idea is that we take money from those that didn't assume and give it to those who did so that they hurt a little less and we all stay afloat."

NEXT: What happens if the stimulus fails?

Last updated April 14 2009: 11:56 AM ET
More Galleries
Top luxurious hotel suites for business travelers For many people, you can't put a price on comfort. More
Million-dollar startups: These firms scored big sales their first year Their first year in business, these companies generated $1 million in sales. More
The 10 best states for retirees It might be worth moving to a new place to find your dream retirement home. Check out these 10 states. More

Special Offer